Dietary advice for muscularity, leanness and weight control in Men’s Health magazine: a content analysis

Abstract

BackgroundThe dietary content of advice in men’s lifestyle magazines has not been closely scrutinised.MethodsWe carried out an analysis of such content in all 2009 issues (n = 11) of Men’s Health (MH) focusing on muscularity, leanness and weight control.ResultsPromotion of a mesomorphic body image underpinned advice to affect muscle building and control weight. Diet advice was underpinned by a strong pseudo-scientific discourse, with citation of expert sources widely used to legitimise the information. Frequently multiple dietary components were advocated within one article e.g. fat, omega-3 fatty acids, thiamine, zinc and high-glycaemic index foods. Furthermore advice would cover numerous nutritional effects, e.g. strengthening bones, reducing stress and boosting testosterone, with little contextualisation. The emphasis on attainment of a mesomorphic body image permitted promotion of slimming diets.Advice to increase calorie and protein intake to augment muscle mass was frequent (183 and 262 references, respectively). Such an anabolic diet was advised in various ways, including consumption of traditional protein foods (217 references) and sports foods (107 references), thereby replicating muscle magazines’ support for nutritional supplements. Although advice to increase consumption of red meat was common (52 references), fish and non-flesh sources of protein (eggs, nuts & pulses, and soy products) together exceeded red meat in number of recommendations (206 references). Advice widely asserted micronutrients and phytochemicals from plant food (161 references) as being important in muscle building. This emphasis diverges from stereotypical gender-based food consumption patterns.Dietary advice for control of body weight largely replicated that of muscularity, with strong endorsement to consume fruits and vegetables (59 references), diets rich in nuts and pulses and fish (66 references), as well as specific micronutrients and phytochemicals (62 references). Notably there was emphasis on fat-burning, good fats and consumption of single foods, with relatively little mention of dietary restriction.ConclusionsDespite the widespread use of scientific information to endorse dietary advice, the content, format and scientific basis of dietary content of MH leaves much to be desired. The dietary advice as provided may not be conducive to public health.

Why rational argument fails the genetic modification (GM) debate

“…Notably, our Science-phile cluster had negative scores on beliefs about the sanctity of food, which may reflect its gender composition. Furthermore, only 1.4% of this cluster was vegetarian, consistent with the food values of hegemonic masculinity (Cook et al 2014). Fig.…”

Men and masculinity in men's magazines: A review

“…Initially, early studies analysed men's magazines for the absence or presence of images and stories of weight loss and nutrition (Andersen & DiDomenico, ; Nemeroff, Stein, Diehl, & Smilack, ). Subsequently, magazines have become a popular research site for analysing male body‐image concerns with the development and testing of body‐image or self‐esteem measures, and a focus on dietary advice and muscularity (Cook, Russell, & Barker, ). For example, Morry and Staska's () study measured levels of body‐image dissatisfaction in a sample of young college men and women after each group read beauty and fitness magazines.…”

Men’s weight loss stories: How personal confession, responsibility and transformation work as social control

“…Yet, to date, there has been limited research into media about weight loss success stories and very little research about men's weight loss stories in particular. There have been examinations of Men's Health magazine, its various components and related websites (see, for example, Alexander, 2003;Bennett and Gough, 2012;Cook et al, 2014;Crawshaw, 2007;Labre, 2005;Newman, 2005;Stibbe, 2004Stibbe, , 2012, but none specifically examine the weight stories presented in this popular magazine. Our previous work considers men's weight loss stories from Men's Health magazine against clinical guidelines for the management of obesity (Couch et al, 2014).…”