Diclofenac poisoning as a cause of vulture population declines across the Indian subcontinent

Abstract

Summary1. Rapid population declines of the vultures Gyps bengalensis , Gyps indicus and Gyps tenuirostris have recently been observed in India and Pakistan, continuing at least up to 2003. Surveys indicate annual rates of decline of 22 -50% for G. bengalensis and G. indicus during 2000-03. Previous studies in Pakistan have shown that the non-steroidal antiinflammatory drug diclofenac causes renal failure and is lethal to G. bengalensis when it feeds on the carcass of a domestic animal that received a normal veterinary dose shortly before death. In Pakistan, diclofenac poisoning was found to be by far the most frequent cause of death. 2. A simulation model of vulture demography, described in this paper, demonstrated that the observed rates of population decline could be caused by contamination with a lethal level of diclofenac in a small proportion (between 1 : 130 and 1 : 760) of ungulate carcasses available to vultures. 3. Proportions of adult and subadult vultures found dead or dying in the wild that had signs of diclofenac poisoning were similar to the proportions of deaths expected from the model if the observed population decline was due entirely to diclofenac poisoning. The proportion of the excess mortality required to cause the observed population declines that could be attributable to diclofenac was estimated to be between 71% and 100%, depending on model assumptions. However, across all or most of the plausible range of assumed values for adult survival, the upper 95% confidence limit for the proportion of excess mortality due to diclofenac was 100%. Hence, available data are consistent with diclofenac poisoning being at least the major cause, and possibly the only cause, of rapid population declines of Gyps vultures across the Indian subcontinent. 4. Synthesis and applications . We recommend that urgent action is taken in the range states of the three currently threatened vulture species to prevent the exposure of vultures to livestock carcasses contaminated with diclofenac. Research is also needed to identify alternative drugs that are effective in livestock and safe for vultures. Efforts should also be made to raise awareness, among veterinarians, pharmacists, livestock owners and the general public, of the problem of diclofenac contamination and the availability of safe alternatives. Captive holding and breeding of vultures until diclofenac is controlled is recommended as a precaution to ensure the long-term survival of the threatened species and to provide a stock of birds for future reintroduction programmes.

Provisioning nest material for Rooks; a potential tool for conservation management

“…Improving complex systems is often time consuming, thus conservationists may choose temporary solutions of directly providing scarce resources (Robb et al 2008, Cortés-Avizanda et al 2010. Consider the example of the declin-ing European vultures, where the change in habitat usage altered animal husbandry, consequently creating a large scale shortage in carcasses (Wallace & Temple 1987, Green et al 2004, Bose & Sarrazin 2007, Deygout et al 2009). However, in certain cases, a network of supplementary feeding stations coupled with the promotion of vulture-friendly livestock keeping proved to be effective in halting the decline (Hous ton 2005).…”

Invited Commentary: Fifty Years of Raptor Research

“…This drug may have killed outright far more raptors than DDT, whose main effect was sublethal. A demographic model showed that if only 0.13-0.75% of carcasses were contaminated by diclofenac in vulture foraging areas in India, populations would be extirpated within a few years (Green et al 2004). Vultures emerged as especially vulnerable to this drug, which produced characteristic symptoms of uric acid crystals deposited around the gut.…”

Role of Cyclonic Storm as Natural Disaster and other Factors on Vulture Mortality in India

“…There was more than 10, 000 loss of human lives and uncountable death of wild life including many birds. [55][56][57][58]. Due to large feather size and heavy weight it might have difficult on their part to leave the place prior to cyclone struck their habitat area.…”