Diagnosis of a severe congenital anomaly: A qualitative analysis of parental decision making and the implications for healthcare encounters

Abstract

ObjectiveTo explore parental decision making following diagnosis of a severe congenital anomaly, and implications for healthcare encounters.DesignQualitative semi‐structured interviews with 38 parents‐to‐be were collated and triangulated with data generated from consultation recordings.AnalysisData were analysed using a constant comparative‐based approach.SettingRecruitment was undertaken across four fetal medicine sites in two tertiary referral trusts.ParticipantsParents‐to‐be whose pregnancy was suspected or diagnosed as being affected by a severe congenital anomaly. This sample was purposive to include known factors affecting the decision to terminate or continue the affected pregnancy.FindingsIn trying to make a decision about how to proceed with their pregnancy, parents‐to‐be typically had to work hard to negotiate multiple uncertainties around the diagnosis and prognosis of the suspected anomaly. This was influenced by parents’ capacity to cope with uncertainty and the way in which uncertainty was managed by the clinical team. This negotiation of uncertainty was enacted within a fluid, nonlinear three‐phase process: “information seeking,” reflecting the way parents‐to‐be face the uncertainty associated with a fetal diagnosis and associated prognosis; “implications,” where consideration is given to future consequences of the decision; and “decision making,” which reflects the way in which the decision is made (head‐ or heart‐led). Spectrums of responses were apparent within each phase.ConclusionsThis study provides important insights into how parents‐to‐be make decisions following diagnosis or suspicion of a severe congenital anomaly. The impact of these on healthcare encounters is discussed, alongside recommendations for clinical practice.

‘They don't know themselves, so how can they tell us?’: parents navigating uncertainty at the frontiers of neonatal surgery

“…In the context of decision‐making about whether to terminate a pregnancy following identification of a severe congenital anomaly, Lotto et al . () highlight how one strategy for alleviating uncertainty and reaching acceptance widely engaged in by parents‐to‐be was that of information seeking. In their study, this manifested in two main ways: activities such as Internet searches or accessing organisations online; and participating in monitoring or further testing to obtain additional clinical information or provide confirmation of the potential diagnoses or prognoses.…”

Congenital cardiac surgery and parental perception of risk: a qualitative study

“…Previous studies exploring the decisionmaking processes of parents have highlighted the potential for relationship breakdown, where responsibility is assumed by one party. 18 Consideration is therefore needed to identify the most effective way of supporting families, whilst taking individual needs and characteristics into consideration. Whilst this study has provided an insight into parental perception of risk, there remains a need to triangulate these findings with the perceptions of clinicians.…”

Perinatal Palliative Care Birth Planning as Advance Care Planning

“…A qualitative study that described if and how parents decide to proceed with a pregnancy when a diagnosis is made highlighted a three phase process families experience that includes information gathering, assessing implications of multiple uncertainties, and ultimately decision making (35). The manner in which information is presented, as well as parental perception of provider's views, affect the parents' experience and potentially informed decision making (17).…”