“…Moreover, because of the low accuracy of microdrilling, d 18 C and d 13 C results could reflect mixing with later burial overgrowths and cements. Oxygen and carbon isotope signatures have already been acquired for well-developed early cements such as microbially generated fabrics, botryoidal cements (Christ et al, 2012a), radiaxial and fascicular fibrous cements (Tobin et al, 1996;Christ et al, 2012a;Dickson & Kenter, 2014), pendant cements (Ronchi et al, 2010;Brigaud et al, 2014b;Dickson & Kenter, 2014) and scalenohedral cements (Godet et al, 2016). However, such measurements are limited to exceptionally well-developed early cements; they do not reflect all the variability of cement types, especially since similar morphologies may have different geochemical compositions and, above all, they do not inform on the intra-cement variability.…”