Developmental Differences Between Boys and Girls Result in Sex-Specific Physical Fitness Changes From Fourth to Fifth Grade

Abstract

To better understand how developmental differences impact performance on a broad selection of common physical fitness measures, we examined changes in boys and girls from fourth to fifth grade. Subjects included 273 boys (age, 9.5 ± 0.6 years; height, 139.86 ± 7.52 cm; mass, 38.00 ± 9.55 kg) and 295 girls (age, 9.6 ± 0.5 years; height, 139.30 ± 7.19 cm; weight, 37.44 ± 9.35 kg). We compared anthropometrics, cardiorespiratory and local muscular endurance, flexibility, power, and strength. A mixed-method analysis of variance was used to compare boys and girls at the 2 time points. Pearson correlation coefficients were used to examine relationships between anthropometric and fitness measurements. Significance was set at p ≤ 0.05. Weight increased significantly (>10%) in both sexes, and girls became significantly taller than boys after growing 4.9% by fifth grade (vs. 3.5%). Both groups improved cardiorespiratory endurance and power, although boys performed better than girls at both time points. Boys were stronger in fourth grade, but girls improved more, leading to similar fifth-grade values. Girls were more flexible in fourth grade, but their significant decreases (∼32.4%) coupled with large improvements in boys (∼105%) resulted in similar fifth-grade scores. Body mass index (BMI) was positively correlated with run time regardless of grade or sex. Power was negatively correlated with BMI and run time in fourth grade. In conclusion, sex-specific differences in physical fitness are apparent before pubescence. Furthermore, this selection of measures reveals sexually dimorphic changes, which likely reflect the onset of puberty in girls. Coaches and teachers should account these developmental differences and their effects on anthropometrics and fitness in boys and girls.

Cardiorespiratory fitness and health‐related quality of life in adolescents: A longitudinal analysis from the LabMed Physical Activity Study

“…In our study, cardiorespiratory fitness significantly decreased over 2 years in girls and increased slightly in boys, although only the changes in girls showed significant statistical difference. Our results are similar to other studies (Catley & Tomkinson, ; Ferrari, Bracco, Matsudo, & Fisberg, ; Flanagan et al, ; Marta, Marinho, Barbosa, Izquierdo, & Marques, ; Santos et al, ), particularly an eight‐year follow‐up study of 86 Portuguese children (44 girls) from the European Youth Heart Study, which showed that cardiorespiratory fitness significantly increased in boys and decreased in girls (Ornelas, Silva, Minderico, & Sardinha, ).…”

Muscular Grip Strength Estimates of the U.S. Population From the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 2011–2012

“…Grip strength by body weight status among U.S. youth was recently reported, but findings were limited to mean values for boys and girls aged 6-15 years and did not provide percentile information for children (10). Recent data on changes in grip strength from fourth to fifth grades showed small increases for the girls but not for the boys from year to year (12). Normative grip strength estimates have also been reported for Canadian men and women across age groups, and additionally, grip strength cut points corresponding to health benefit zones (HBZs) have been established (4,5,33).…”

Physical fitness disparities among New York City public school youth using standardized methods, 2006-2017

“…Marta et al found that boys demonstrated higher aerobic fitness, speed, and strength and girls had higher flexibility scores [48]. Flanagan et al similarly found that boys' cardiorespiratory endurance and power performance was higher than for girls in both the fourth and fifth grades [49]. Moreover, Messiah et al found that boys aged 9-16 had significantly higher fitness scores compared with girls for the PACER, sit-up and push-up tests [50].…”