Developmental Cut-Points for Atypical Speech Intelligibility in Children With Cerebral Palsy

Abstract

Purpose: Early identification of speech motor involvement (SMI) in children with cerebral palsy (CP) is difficult because of overlapping features with many aspects of typical speech development. Quantitative measures of speech intelligibility have the potential to differentiate between children with SMI and those with no SMI (NSMI). We examined thresholds for speech intelligibility development in children with CP relative to the low end of age-specific typical developmental expectations. We sought to determine whether there were intelligibility differences between children with CP and NSMI versus typically developing (TD) age-mates across the range of development and whether there were differences between children with CP who have NSMI and those with CP who have SMI across the range of development based on speech intelligibility. Method: We used two large existing data sets that included speech samples from children between the ages of 2.5 and 8 years. One data set included 511 longitudinal speech samples from children with CP; the other included 505 cross-sectional speech samples from TD children. We examined receiver operating characteristic curves and sensitivity/specificity results by age for differentiating among groups of children. Results: TD children versus those with CP and NSMI showed differentiation in their speech intelligibility across all ages, but the strength of differentiation was only marginally above chance. Children with CP and NSMI showed clear differentiation in their speech intelligibility from those with CP and SMI beginning at the earliest age point. Children with CP who have intelligibility below 40% at the age of 3 years have a very high probability of having SMI. Conclusions: Early intelligibility screening should be performed in children diagnosed with CP. Those with intelligibility below 40% at 3 years of age should be referred immediately for speech assessment and treatment.

Speech development between 30 and 119 months in typical children III: Interaction between speaking rate and intelligibility

“…The present paper is the third in a series (see Hustad et al, 2021;Mahr et al, 2021) focused on quantifying developmental change in functional measures of speech in typical children. Our earlier papers established important normative benchmarks for the development of speech intelligibility and articulation rate that lay a foundation for the identification of children who do not meet age level expectations (Hustad, Mahr, Soriano, & Rathouz, 2023) and may therefore require further assessment and subsequent intervention. However, the intersection of rate and intelligibility has not yet been examined, and therefore we do not know the extent to which speech rate impacts intelligibility in children.…”