Development of the PC-7, a Quantifiable Assessment of Spiritual Concerns of Patients Receiving Palliative Care Near the End of Life

Abstract

Background: Attending to the religious/spiritual (R/S) concerns of patients is a core component of palliative care. A primary responsibility of the chaplain is to conduct a thorough assessment of palliative care patients' R/S needs and resources. Problems with current approaches to spiritual assessment in all clinical contexts, including palliative care, include limited evidence for their validity, reliability, or clinical usefulness; narrative content; and lack of clinical specificity. Objectives: The aim of our work was to develop an evidence-based, quantifiable model for the assessment of unmet spiritual concerns of palliative care patients near the end of life. Design: The PC-7 model was developed by a team of chaplains working in palliative care. Phase 1 used literature in the field and the chaplains' clinical practice to identify key concerns in the spiritual care of palliative care patients. Phase 2 focused on developing indicators of those concerns and reliability in the chaplains' rating of them. Results: Key concerns in the model include the following. Need for meaning in the face of suffering; need for integrity, a legacy; concerns about relationships; concern or fear about dying or death; issues related to treatment decision making; R/S struggle; and other concerns. An approach to scoring the patients' degree of unmet spiritual concerns was adapted from the literature. Assessing cases from the chaplains' practice led to high levels of agreement (reliability). Conclusion: Using the PC-7 model, chaplains can describe and quantify the key spiritual concerns of palliative care patients. Further research is needed to test its validity, reliability, and clinical usefulness.

The Urgency of Spiritual Care: COVID-19 and the Critical Need for Whole-Person Palliation

“…There are several tools available, some of which are quantifiable and specific to patients receiving palliative care near the end of life. 15 The FICA (faith, import or influence, community, address) 16 tool (Ó Puchalski) is convenient to use in any setting and may be adapted for COVID-19 specific considerations ( Table 1). The BELIEF (belief system, ethics or values, lifestyle, involvement in spiritual community, education, near future events of spiritual significance for which to prepare the child) model by McEvoy is an option for pediatric care.…”

What Did Chaplains Do During the Covid Pandemic? An International Survey

“…One of the major casualties of this agenda was the spiritual dimension, precisely the dimension represented by chaplains (Kelly, 2013). For many patients and their families, coping with illness, traumatic events and facing the end of life are not just medical issues, they are deeply spiritual issues ( Fitchett et al., 2020 ). However, patients, staff and relatives had become isolated from each other as a consequence of the measures designed to save them.…”

A New Paradigm for Testing Clinical Competence in Chaplaincy Certification

“…Lastly, it is conjectured that this scoring system would make it much harder to maintain reliability. That said, the work of Massey and colleagues in developing standard language to describe chaplain activities and the work of Fitchett and colleagues in developing a new spiritual assessment tool both exhibited a high degree of interrater reliability in a relatively short period of time raising the possibility that there is more commonality in how chaplains understand what they do than many have anticipated (Fitchett et al., 2019; Massey et al., 2015).…”