“…ACE and RapidINTEL utilize the GlobalFiler set of 21 autosomal STRs, one Y-STR, one Y-chromosome InDel, and amelogenin. Publication | Instrument | Cartridge/Kit | Test Performed and Success Rates Reported |
Amick & Swiger 2019 [ 56 ] | RapidHIT ID | ACE and EXT | Performed SWGDAM internal validation studies including known and database-type samples, reproducibility, precision, sensitivity, stochastic effects, mixtures, contamination assessment, and concordance studies |
Carney et al, 2019 [ 57 ] | ANDE 6C | A-Chip | Conducted SWGDAM developmental validation (across 6 labs, 2045 swabs, 13 instruments): species specificity, limit of detection, stability, inhibitors, reproducibility, reference material, mixtures, precision, concordance, signal strength, peak height ratio, stutter, non-template addition, resolution, and contamination assessment; first-pass success rate (1338 samples with 20 CODIS core loci) = 92% ; successfully interpreted >2000 samples with over 99.99% concordant alleles; data package led to receiving NDIS approval in June 2018 |
Shackleton et al, 2019 [ 58 ] | RapidHIT ID | NGM SElect Express | Described development studies that included process optimization, sensitivity, repeatability, contamination checks, inhibition, swab age, concordance, and overall performance; success rate (124 samples) = 84.5% gave a full profile |
Shackleton et al, 2019 [ 59 ] | RapidHIT 200 | NGM SElect Express | Performed some protocol adjustments that enhanced slightly the sensitivity with mock crime scene samples (dilutions of blood and cell line DNA) |
Yang et al, 2019 [ 53 ] | MiDAS | PowerPlex ESI 16 Plus | Described protocols for analysis of reference samples with a fully automated integrated microfluidic system (MiDAS), which is not commercially available |
Romsos et al, 2020 [ 48 ] | ANDE 6C, RapidHIT ID, RapidHIT 200 | A-Chip, ACE | Reported results from the July 2018 rapid DNA maturity assessment with multiple instruments organized by NIST; the average success rate for obtaining the 20 CODIS core loci was 85% (n=240) |
Manzella & Moreno 2020 [ |
…”