“…Thereafter, the chemical transformation methods (Nørgard, Keem & Monahan, 1978;Dagert & Ehrlich, 1979;Zhang, Xu & Xu, 2004) have continuously been modified with various combinations of chemical solutions including different cations (Mg 2+ , Ca 2+ , Sr 2+ , Ba 2+ , Mn 2+ , K + , Na + , Rb + ), PEG, DMSO (Chung & Miller, 1988;Chan et al, 2013) and glycerin Shanehbandi et al (2013). Considering the practicality and convenience of different artificial methods, more efficient exogenous gene transfer systems also have been developed by physical or chemical methods, including chemical procedures (Inoue, Nojima & Okayama, 1990;Sarkar, Choudhuri & Basu, 2002a;Sarkar, Choudhuri & Basu, 2002b;Song et al, 2007), high-voltage electroporation (Dower, Miller & Ragsdale, 1988;Dunny, Lee & LeBlanc, 1991;Sheng, Mancino & Birren, 1995), a biolistic propulsion system (Shark et al, 1991), liposome-mediated DNA transfer (Kawata, Yano & Kojima, 2003), microwaves and ultrasounds assisted DNA transfer (Zarnitsyn & Prausnitz, 2004;Fregel, Rodriguez & Cabrera, 2008;Tripp, Maza & Young, 2013;Deeks et al, 2014) and chemicalphysical (Rb + , sepiolite and nanomaterials) induced transformation (Ren et al, 2017;Ren, Na & Yoo, 2018;Ren et al, 2019), etc. The transformation efficiency (10 4∼10 8 CFU/µg DNA) of different strains can obviously be obtained from these methods described.…”