Hydroxyurea (HU), an anti-metabolite ribonucleotide reductase inhibitor, is commonly used to treat several myeloproliferative disorders, including polycythemia vera. However, patients receiving long-term treatment with HU may experience a variety of cutaneous side effects, with non-melanoma skin cancers (NMSCs) emerging as the most challenging and destructive. HU-induced carcinogenesis can be attributed to both the drug's mutagenic potential and impaired DNA repair following damage by external triggers such as ultraviolet light. We report a unique case of multiple aggressive NMSCs distributed within sun-exposed areas in an 81-year-old woman receiving chronic therapy with HU for 15 years. The case draws the clinician's attention to the increased incidence of NMSCs in this population and highlights the need for regular dermatologic monitoring. We also elaborate relevant insights and recommendations to assist healthcare providers in managing HU-related NMSCs development and progression.