Development of a new Emergency Medicine Spinal Immobilization Protocol for trauma patients and a test of applicability by German emergency care providers
Abstract: BackgroundIn order to match the challenges of quickly recognizing and treating any life-threatening injuries, the ABCDE principles were established for the assessment and treatment of trauma patients. The high priority of spine protection is emphasized by the fact that immobilization of the cervical spine is performed at the very first step in the ABCDE principles. Immobilization is typically performed to prevent or minimize secondary damage to the spinal cord if instability of the spinal column is suspected. … Show more
Search citation statements
Paper Sections
Citation Types
Year Published
Publication Types
Relationship
Authors
Journals
Cited by 38 publications
References 62 publications
Objetivo: Identificar efectos perjudiciales causados por la estabilización de la columna vertebral en la víctima de trauma y situaciones de trauma sin indicación para estabilización de la columna vertebral en el prehospitalario.Método: Se trata de una revisión integrativa de literatura orientada por las cuestiones de investigación: ¿Existe evidencia científica de efectos perjudiciales en las víctimas de trauma, causados por la estabilización de la columna vertebral en el cuidado prehospitalario? y ¿Existen situaciones de trauma sin indicación para estabilización de la columna vertebral?Resultados: Se realizó una investigación booleana en las bases electrónicas Cochrane Library y Pubmed ya través del motor EBSCOhost en las bases de datos CINAHL Plus, MEDLINE, MedicLatina, SPORTDiscus, PsycBras, PsycBOOKS, Psychología y Behavioral Sciences Collection, Academic Search Complete. Se obtuvieron doce artículos y tras la aplicación de los criterios de inclusión y exclusión constituyen la muestra cinco artículos.Conclusiones: Se describen efectos perjudiciales de la estabilización de la columna vertebral en la víctima de trauma relacionados con la gestión de la vía aérea, dolor, malestar y lesiones por presión.Las situaciones de trauma penetrante con circulación inestable y víctimas con lesiones por arma de fuego en la cabeza no carecen de estabilización de la columna vertebral.Se han reunido recomendaciones de apoyo a la decisión prehospitalaria en cuanto a la estabilización de la columna vertebral.Es crucial para la mejora del cuidado prehospitalario, integrar un enfoque individualizado de la víctima que se refiera a su estado clínico y al mecanismo de lesión. Goal: To identify harmful effects caused by the stabilization of the vertebral column in a trauma victim and in trauma situations without indication for stabilization of the spine in the prehospital.Method: It was perform an integrative literature review guided by research questions: is there a scientific evidence of harmful effects on trauma victims caused by spinal stabilization in prehospital care? and are there situations of trauma with no indication for stabilization of the spine?Results: We have performed a Boolean search in the electronic bases Cochrane Library and Pubmed and through the EBSCOhost engine in the databases CINAHL Plus, MEDLINE, MedicLatina, SPORTDiscus, PsycARTICLES, PsycBOOKS, Psychology and Behavioral Sciences Collection, Academic Search Complete. Twelve articles were obtained and after applying the inclusion and exclusion criteria, the sample was five articles.Conclusions: Harmful effects of spinal stabilization on the victim of trauma related to airway management, pain, discomfort and pressure injuries are described.Situations of penetrating trauma with unstable circulation and victims with gunshot injuries to the head do not require stabilization of the spine.Recommendations to support the prehospital decision regarding stabilization of the spine were collected.It is crucial for the improvement of prehospital care to integrate an individualized approach of the victim that refers to its clinical state and mechanism of injury. Objetivo: Identificar efeitos prejudiciais causados pela estabilização da coluna vertebral na vítima de trauma e situações de trauma sem indicação para estabilização da coluna vertebral no pré-hospitalar.Método: Trata-se de uma revisão integrativa de literatura norteada pelas questões de pesquisa: existe evidência científica de efeitos prejudiciais nas vítimas de trauma, causados pela estabilização da coluna vertebral no cuidado pré-hospitalar? e existem situações de trauma sem indicação para estabilização da coluna vertebral?Resultados: Foi realizada pesquisa booleana nas bases eletrónicas Cochrane Library e Pubmed e através do motor EBSCOhost nas bases de dados CINAHL Plus, MEDLINE, MedicLatina, SPORTDiscus, PsycARTICLES, PsycBOOKS, Psychology and Behavioral Sciences Collection, Academic Search Complete. Obtiveram-se doze artigos e após aplicação dos critérios de inclusão e exclusão constitui a amostra cinco artigos.Conclusões: Estão descritos efeitos prejudiciais da estabilização da coluna vertebral na vítima de trauma relacionados com a gestão da via aérea, dor, desconforto e lesões por pressão.Situações de trauma penetrante com circulação instável e vítimas com lesões por arma de fogo na cabeça não carecem de estabilização da coluna vertebral.Foram reunidas recomendações de apoio à decisão pré-hospitalar quanto à estabilização da coluna vertebral.É crucial para a melhoria do cuidado pré-hospitalar, integrar uma abordagem individualizada da vítima que se refira ao seu estado clínico e ao mecanismo de lesão.
Objetivo: Identificar efectos perjudiciales causados por la estabilización de la columna vertebral en la víctima de trauma y situaciones de trauma sin indicación para estabilización de la columna vertebral en el prehospitalario.Método: Se trata de una revisión integrativa de literatura orientada por las cuestiones de investigación: ¿Existe evidencia científica de efectos perjudiciales en las víctimas de trauma, causados por la estabilización de la columna vertebral en el cuidado prehospitalario? y ¿Existen situaciones de trauma sin indicación para estabilización de la columna vertebral?Resultados: Se realizó una investigación booleana en las bases electrónicas Cochrane Library y Pubmed ya través del motor EBSCOhost en las bases de datos CINAHL Plus, MEDLINE, MedicLatina, SPORTDiscus, PsycBras, PsycBOOKS, Psychología y Behavioral Sciences Collection, Academic Search Complete. Se obtuvieron doce artículos y tras la aplicación de los criterios de inclusión y exclusión constituyen la muestra cinco artículos.Conclusiones: Se describen efectos perjudiciales de la estabilización de la columna vertebral en la víctima de trauma relacionados con la gestión de la vía aérea, dolor, malestar y lesiones por presión.Las situaciones de trauma penetrante con circulación inestable y víctimas con lesiones por arma de fuego en la cabeza no carecen de estabilización de la columna vertebral.Se han reunido recomendaciones de apoyo a la decisión prehospitalaria en cuanto a la estabilización de la columna vertebral.Es crucial para la mejora del cuidado prehospitalario, integrar un enfoque individualizado de la víctima que se refiera a su estado clínico y al mecanismo de lesión. Goal: To identify harmful effects caused by the stabilization of the vertebral column in a trauma victim and in trauma situations without indication for stabilization of the spine in the prehospital.Method: It was perform an integrative literature review guided by research questions: is there a scientific evidence of harmful effects on trauma victims caused by spinal stabilization in prehospital care? and are there situations of trauma with no indication for stabilization of the spine?Results: We have performed a Boolean search in the electronic bases Cochrane Library and Pubmed and through the EBSCOhost engine in the databases CINAHL Plus, MEDLINE, MedicLatina, SPORTDiscus, PsycARTICLES, PsycBOOKS, Psychology and Behavioral Sciences Collection, Academic Search Complete. Twelve articles were obtained and after applying the inclusion and exclusion criteria, the sample was five articles.Conclusions: Harmful effects of spinal stabilization on the victim of trauma related to airway management, pain, discomfort and pressure injuries are described.Situations of penetrating trauma with unstable circulation and victims with gunshot injuries to the head do not require stabilization of the spine.Recommendations to support the prehospital decision regarding stabilization of the spine were collected.It is crucial for the improvement of prehospital care to integrate an individualized approach of the victim that refers to its clinical state and mechanism of injury. Objetivo: Identificar efeitos prejudiciais causados pela estabilização da coluna vertebral na vítima de trauma e situações de trauma sem indicação para estabilização da coluna vertebral no pré-hospitalar.Método: Trata-se de uma revisão integrativa de literatura norteada pelas questões de pesquisa: existe evidência científica de efeitos prejudiciais nas vítimas de trauma, causados pela estabilização da coluna vertebral no cuidado pré-hospitalar? e existem situações de trauma sem indicação para estabilização da coluna vertebral?Resultados: Foi realizada pesquisa booleana nas bases eletrónicas Cochrane Library e Pubmed e através do motor EBSCOhost nas bases de dados CINAHL Plus, MEDLINE, MedicLatina, SPORTDiscus, PsycARTICLES, PsycBOOKS, Psychology and Behavioral Sciences Collection, Academic Search Complete. Obtiveram-se doze artigos e após aplicação dos critérios de inclusão e exclusão constitui a amostra cinco artigos.Conclusões: Estão descritos efeitos prejudiciais da estabilização da coluna vertebral na vítima de trauma relacionados com a gestão da via aérea, dor, desconforto e lesões por pressão.Situações de trauma penetrante com circulação instável e vítimas com lesões por arma de fogo na cabeça não carecem de estabilização da coluna vertebral.Foram reunidas recomendações de apoio à decisão pré-hospitalar quanto à estabilização da coluna vertebral.É crucial para a melhoria do cuidado pré-hospitalar, integrar uma abordagem individualizada da vítima que se refira ao seu estado clínico e ao mecanismo de lesão.
Because spinal cord injuries can have fatal consequences for injured race car drivers, prehospital treatment of spinal injuries is a major concern in motor sports. A structured procedure for assessing trauma patients and their treatment should follow established ABCDE principles. Only then, a stable patient could be further examined and appropriate measures can be undertaken. For patients in an acute life-threatening condition, rapid transport must be initiated and should not be delayed by measures that are not indicated. If a competitor must first be extricated from the racing vehicle, the correct method of extrication must be chosen. To avoid secondary injury to the spine after a racing accident, in-line extrication from the vehicle and immobilization of the patient are standard procedures in motor sports and have been used for decades. Since immobilization can be associated with disadvantages and complications, the need for immobilization of trauma patients outside of motor sports medicine has become the subject of an increasing number of reports in the scientific literature. Even in motor sports, where specific safety systems that offer spinal protection are present, the indications for spinal immobilization need to be carefully considered rather than being blindly adopted as a matter of course. The aim of this article is to use recent literature to present an overview about the treatment of spinal injuries in motor sports. Further, we present a new protocol for indications for immobilizing the spine in motor sports that is based on the ABCDE principles and takes into account the condition of the patient.
BackgroundCurrent guidelines state that trauma patients at risk of spine injury should undergo prehospital spine immobilization to reduce the risk of neurological deterioration. Although this approach has been accepted and implemented as a standard for decades, there is little scientific evidence to support it. Furthermore, the potential dangers and sequelae of spine immobilization have been extensively reported. The role of the paramedic in this process has not yet been examined. The aim of this study was to evaluate the accuracy of prehospital evaluations for the presence of spine fractures made by paramedics.MethodsAll patients who presented with prehospital spine immobilization at our level II trauma center between January 2013 and January 2014 were prospectively included in a database. Prior to the diagnosis, paramedics recorded the probability of a spine fracture after a prehospital examination. These predictions were compared with patient outcomes. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value were calculated.ResultsOne hundred and thirty-nine patients were included that positive predictive value was 22%, negative predictive value was 95%, sensitivity was 92%, specificity was 30%, and accuracy was 41%.ConclusionsThe results of this study suggest that paramedics cannot accurately predict spinal fractures.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
Contact Info
hi@scite.ai
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Product
Resources
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.
