Development of a Concurrent Treatment Technique of Ethyl Formate and Mixtures (Nitrogen, Phosphine) to Control Citrus Mealybug (Planococcus citri)

Abstract

Currently, the fumigant ethyl formate (EF) is stored as a liquified gas in metal cylinders mixed with carbon dioxide (CO2), but this product type is expensive to manufacture, transport, and maintain in cylinders. To address these problems, we developed a new EF fumigation technique with a nitrogen (N2) carrier. In this report, the susceptibility of citrus mealybugs, one of the most resistant mealybugs to fumigants, to EF was assessed; the phytotoxicity of an EF + N2 concurrent treatment applied to banana fruit was examined to evaluate the efficacy compared to the current EF + CO2 product; and the increased efficacy with a phosphine (PH3) addition to EF + N2 was also assessed. Concurrent treatment of EF and N2 was performed at an LC50 concentration of EF. N2 was applied in seven doses from concentrations of 79% to 95%. The phytotoxicity of EF to bananas was assessed by applying EF at 35 mg/L with N2 at 79%, and the color, sugar content, and weight loss of bananas were measured for 14 days after treatment. The EF with N2 treatment resulted in more than 50% mortality at all growth stages of the mealybug, and there was no significant difference between the untreated and treated banana fruits. EF mixed with PH3 showed a higher efficacy than treatment with EF alone, but only a slight increase in efficacy was observed when the PH3 concentration increased. These results indicate that concurrent treatment with EF and N2 can be used to control mealybugs on banana fruits, and combined treatment with EF and PH3 can also enhance the efficacy against mealybugs.