Developing a tool to assess the skills to perform a health technology assessment

Abstract

Background Health technology assessment (HTA) brings together evidence from various disciplines while using explicit methods to assess the value of health technologies. In resource-constrained settings, there is a growing demand to measure and develop specialist skills, including those for HTA, to aid the implementation of Universal Healthcare Coverage. The purpose of this study was twofold: a) to find validated tools for the assessment of the technical capacity to conduct a HTA, and if none were found, to develop a tool, and b) to describe experiences of its pilot. Methods First, a mapping review identified tools to assess the skills to conduct a HTA. A medical librarian conducted a comprehensive search in four databases (MEDLINE, Embase, Web of Science, ERIC). Then, incorporating results from the mapping and following an iterative process involving stakeholders and experts, we developed a HTA skills assessment tool. Finally, using an online platform to gather and analyse responses, in collaboration with our institutional partner, we piloted the tool in Ghana, and sought feedback on their experiences. Results The database search yielded 3871 records; fifteen those were selected based on a priori criteria. These records were published between 2003 and 2018, but none covered all technical skills to conduct a HTA. In the absence of an instrument meeting our needs, we developed a HTA skill assessment tool containing four sections (general information, core and soft skills, and future needs). The tool was designed to be administered to a broad range of individuals who would potentially contribute to the planning, delivery and evaluation of HTA. The tool was piloted with twenty-three individuals who completed the skills assessment and shared their initial impressions of the tool. Conclusions To our knowledge, this is the first comprehensive tool enabling the assessment of technical skills to conduct a HTA. This tool allows teams to understand where their individual strengths and weakness lie. The tool is in the early validation phases and further testing is needed. Trial registration Not applicable.

Health Technology Assessment (HTA) readiness in Uganda: Stakeholder’s perceptions on the potential application of HTA to support National Universal Health Coverage efforts

“…HTA has been highlighted by the WHO as one of the tools that can propel countries towards UHC if implemented. Examples of countries recently introducing HTA in decision making include Ghana 15,18 , India 19 , Kenya 20 , Indonesia 21 , and the Philippines 22 . Uganda is committed to the achievement of UHC by 2030 through strengthening the health system and its support mechanisms with a specific focus on primary health care 23 .…”

An Objective Structured Laboratory Animal Science Examination (OSLASE) to ensure researchers’ professional competence in laboratory animal science

“…9 The topic of how OSLASE helps the trainee to confirm the skills acquired emerged several times during the interviews, confirming the perception that assessment is an essential step in the consolidation and promotion of future practical learning. 29,30 The trainees also reported that the OSLASE establishes a standard and defines the skills that students are expected to develop in subsequent sessions. They also felt that demonstrations contributed to the identification of skills that should be improved and to the support of the role of those overseeing workplace training, which are crucial features introduced by the assessment in the context of these courses.…”

Data Quality of Different Modes of Supervision in Classroom Surveys

“…Atkeson et al (2014) argue that the presence of an interviewer can alter response patterns on questions that pertain to an individual's personal beliefs, attitudes, or experiences. Bidonde et al (2023) found that response rates of adolescents in studies of mental health can indeed vary with survey mode, consent type, and incentives used. Overall, it seemed that when there is any kind of supervision involved, response rates were at least slightly higher.…”

“…When surveys take place in schools, it is common practise to work with teachers as "assistant supervisors", as they are already figures of authority in the target groups and can usually handle group dynamics and disruptions. Although their ability to do so may vary (March et al 2022), this should increase data quality in terms of validity and completion rates (Bidonde et al 2023).…”