Developing a tool for the measurement of social exclusion in healthcare settings

Abstract

Background Social exclusion is a complex concept that is recognised as a key determinant of health. Many measurement tools developed looked at people from single excluded groups in isolation. We know from experience and literature that exclusion is often intersectional and multi-layered. Therefore, the aim of this research was to develop a social exclusion measurement tool for use in healthcare settings with individuals from any excluded group that would include questions to investigate socioeconomic elements and subjective experiences in their lives. Methods Inductive and deductive methods were used to develop the tool. Early drafts were tested with experts (both academic and experts by experience) and modified in line with feedback received. The tool was then piloted with people in the community, and this allowed us to assess the internal consistency and validity of the tool. Exploratory factor analysis was carried out as part of this evaluation. Results The measurement tool was initially evaluated by 17 academic and ‘real world’ experts. It was then piloted with seven experts by experience, two gatekeepers and two participants who were presumed not to be excluded, resulting in the development of the final tool. This was then tested with 276 participants (127 presumed excluded, 149 presumed not excluded). The socioeconomic characteristics of these participants were documented, and exploratory factor analysis was carried out on data relating to subjective items. A four-factor structure emerged comprising 22 items. Internal consistency of the factors was high, and their ability to discriminate between the two groups was notable. Conclusions A tool for measuring the social exclusion of individuals has been developed by engaging with people from a variety of excluded groups. Socioeconomic indicators were combined with subjective items. The input of experts by experience, academics and others was sought to enhance the tool. The tool was applied to two distinct samples, showing obvious differences both in the socioeconomic items, and the items included in the factor analysis. The potential use of this tool could have positive implications for people who are excluded.

Assessing the Key Factors Measuring Regional Competitiveness

“…Social exclusion is a comprehensive concept encompassing various factors that can render specific groups in society vulnerable [63]. These factors include unemployment, limited access to education, childcare, and healthcare facilities, inadequate living conditions, and insufficient social participation, with a particular emphasis on labor market exclusion [64].…”

Barriers and facilitators to refugees and asylum seekers accessing non hospital based care: A mixed methods systematic review protocol.

“…One such research paper was that of O Donnell et al (2022). In this paper the authors engaged with various stakeholders from academic, clinical and political backgrounds, to learn how they defined and conceptualised social exclusion 52 . The authors concluded that the overall definition of social exclusion was the "experience of lack of opportunity, or the inability to make use of available opportunities, thereby preventing full participation in society".…”