Developing a bioethics curriculum for medical students from divergent geo-political regions

Abstract

BackgroundThe World Health Organization calls for stronger cross-cultural emphasis in medical training. Bioethics education can build such competencies as it involves the conscious exploration and application of values and principles. The International Pediatric Emergency Medicine Elective (IPEME), a novel global health elective, brings together 12 medical students from Canada and the Middle East for a 4-week, living and studying experience. It is based at a Canadian children’s hospital and, since its creation in 2004, ethics has informally been part of its curriculum. Our study sought to determine the content and format of an ideal bioethics curriculum for a culturally diverse group of medical students.MethodsWe conducted semi-structured interviews with students and focus groups with faculty to examine the cultural context and ethical issues of the elective. Three areas were explored: 1) Needs Analysis - students' current understanding of bioethics, prior bioethics education and desire for a formal ethics curriculum, 2) Teaching formats - students’ and faculty’s preferred teaching formats, and 3) Curriculum Content - students’ and faculty’s preferred subjects for a curriculum.ResultsWhile only some students had received formal ethics training prior to this program, all understood that it was a necessary and desirable subject for formal training. Interactive teaching formats were the most preferred and truth-telling was considered the most important subject.ConclusionsThis study helps inform good practices for ethics education. Although undertaken with a specific cohort of students engaging in a health-for-peace elective, it may be applicable to many medical education settings since diversity of student bodies is increasing world-wide.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12909-016-0711-4) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

A Novel Peer-Directed Curriculum to Enhance Medical Ethics Training for Medical Students: A Single-Institution Experience

“…Regardless of the pedagogical approach, we encourage an interactive modality (eg small group format, case-based narrative discussions, role-playing, mentoring, shadowing, etc) to promote experiential learning and long-term retention of medical ethics knowledge that can be recalled and later applied to clinical practice. 14 This approach is particularly beneficial for physicians in training where most professionalism, self-awareness, and clinical decision-making is experienced and learned in the clinical training environment. Furthermore, peer-to-peer teaching has been shown to improve student critical thinking skills, group participation and discussion, and interest in learning medical ethics.…”

<p>Knowledge and Attitudes Towards Abortion and Euthanasia Among Health Students in Papua New Guinea</p>

“…Another factor influencing agreement for abortion was religious affiliation and values. 5,[42][43][44] O'Grady et al 45 concluded that religious adherence was the strongest determinant of an Irish medical student's perspective on the ethics of abortion.…”

La responsabilidad: un principio para retomar en la reflexión bioética

“…Una educación que obviamente no esté filtrada por esos intereses, muchas veces sutilmente (45) , sino que sea independiente y trasparente. Es necesaria la inclusión transversal en los currículos de los programas educativos de materias sobre la naturaleza de las ciencias y sostenibilidad ambiental (46,47) , así como el entrenamiento formal y práctico en bioética (48) . Es la reflexión la que puede transformar las formas de actuar.…”