Determination of Radical Re-encounter Probability Distributions from Magnetic Field Effects on Reaction Yields

Abstract

Measurements are reported of the effects of 0-23 mT applied magnetic fields on the spin-selective recombination of Py*- and DMA*+ radicals formed in the photochemical reaction of pyrene and N,N-dimethylaniline. Singlet <--> triplet interconversion in [Py*- DMA*+] radical pairs is probed by investigating combinations of fully protonated and fully deuterated reaction partners. Qualitatively, the experimental B1/2 values for the four isotopomeric radical pairs agree with predictions based on the Weller equation using known hyperfine coupling constants. The amplitude of the "low field effect" (LFE) correlates well with the ratio of effective hyperfine couplings, aDMA/aPy. An efficient method is introduced for calculating the spin evolution of [Py*- DMA*+] radical pairs containing a total of 18 spin-1/2 and spin-1 magnetic nuclei. Quantitative analysis of the magnetic field effects to obtain the radical re-encounter probability distribution f (t )-a highly ill-posed and underdetermined problem-is achieved by means of Tikhonov and maximum entropy regularization methods. The resulting f (t ) functions are very similar for the four isotopomeric radical pairs and have significant amplitude between 2 and 10 ns after the creation of the geminate radical pair. This interval reflects the time scale of re-encounters that are crucial for generating the magnetic field effect. Computer simulations of generalized radical pairs containing six spin-1/2 nuclei show that Weller's equation holds approximately only when the radical pair recombination rate is comparable to the two effective hyperfine couplings and that a substantial LFE requires, but is not guaranteed by, the condition that the two effective hyperfine couplings differ by more than a factor of 5. In contrast, for very slow recombination, essentially any radical pair should show a significant LFE.

Chemical amplification of magnetic field effects relevant to avian magnetoreception

“…That these enhancements have not previously come to light is probably because most studies have either been conducted with pulsed illumination 11,58 or have used magnetic fields that were amplitude-modulated at frequencies faster than the slow reaction steps 59 . The magnitude of the amplification increases with the ratio (k D /k F ) of the rate constants for the oxidation of the flavin radical (k F ) and the reduction of the counter-radical (k D ).…”

Photoreceptor-based magnetoreception: optimal design of receptor molecules, cells, and neuronal processing

“…The importance of the radical-pair symmetry was realized in further studies and it was shown that weak magnetic field effects become most pronounced when the ratio of hyperfine coupling strengths between the two radicals is maximized (Rodgers et al 2007). There is evidence supporting the 'probe' aspect of the 'reference -probe' design in several experiments.…”

Alternative radical pairs for cryptochrome-based magnetoreception

“…We refer to this radical, which could be positively or negatively charged or neutral, as Z † . It was also noted that an [FAD †2 Z † ] radical pair might offer a higher sensitivity to weak magnetic fields than would one with hyperfine interactions in both radicals [19][20][21][22]. This recipe for efficient sensing of the direction of an external magnetic field was subsequently developed into a 'reference-probe' model in which one radical (the reference) has large anisotropic hyperfine interactions and determines the anisotropy of the reaction yields while the other (the probe) has no hyperfine interactions and is responsible for efficiently coupling the radical pair to the magnetic field [11].…”