Determinants of Physician Discussion Regarding Tobacco and Alcohol Abuse

Abstract

The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recommends that clinicians screen adults for tobacco and alcohol abuse and provide appropriate interventions. This study employed direct observation and interactional analysis of medical visits to investigate factors associated with physician discussion of tobacco and alcohol use with patients. New adult patients were randomly assigned to primary care at a university medical center. Videotapes of the visits were analyzed using the Davis observation code. Regression equations related discussions of substance use (alcohol and other substances), smoking, and health promotion to patient health status, depression, age, education, income, gender, alcohol abuse, and current smoking. Patients reporting better physical health were more likely to have their physicians employ a practice style emphasizing addiction behaviors (p = .0186). Substance use (p = .0117) and health promotion counseling (p = .0130) occurred more frequently with younger patients. Physicians discussed substance use (p = < .0001) and addiction (p < .0001) more often with male patients. Problem drinkers were more likely to have physicians address their substance use (p = .0069) and focus on addiction behaviors (p = .0017). Physicians adopted an addiction-oriented practice style (p < .0001), addressing substance use (p = .0009) and smoking (p < .0001), more often with patients who smoked. Physicians appear more apt to discuss these behavioral risk factors with healthier, younger, male patients who abuse tobacco and alcohol.

Using the Extended Parallel Process Model to Explain Physicians' Decisions to Test Their Patients for Kidney Disease

“…One-hundred and twelve physicians completed and returned the second survey, for an overall follow-up response rate of 73.7%. These sample sizes compare favorably with those obtained in other recent health communication studies using a survey research method with physicians as research participants (Bertakis & Azari, 2007;Cegala, Gade, Broz, & McClure, 2004;Kelly, Thompson, & Waters, 2006;Perkins et al, 2007).…”

Predicting Pediatricians' Communication With Parents About the Human Papillomavirus (HPV) Vaccine: An Application of the Theory of Reasoned Action

“…In total, 406 pediatricians completed and returned this survey, for an overall response rate of 34.7%. This sample size compares favorably to those obtained in other recent health communication studies using a survey research method with physicians as research participants ( M = 101, range = 46–152) (Roberto, Goodall, West, & Mahan, 2010; Bertakis & Azari, 2007; Kelly, Thompson, & Waters, 2006). This sample size also compares favorably to the nine TRA studies that used physicians as research patricians reviewed by Perkins et al (2007).…”

Persuading Physicians to Test Their Patients' Level of Kidney Functioning: The Effects of Message Frame and Point of View

“…Third, though our response rate was low, our sample size was actually much larger than the typical studies that include physicians as research participants. For example, studies using physician survey data typically include between 23 and 105 physicians (M = 58; Bertakis & Azari, 2007;Kelly, Thompson, & Waters, 2006;Cegala, Gade, Broz, & McClure, 2004). Fortunately, we were aware of this potential problem before the study began, and were able to begin with a high-quality sample that was large enough to lead to a data set from which meaningful results could still be drawn.…”