The destruction of the immune system by progressive loss of CD4 T cells is the hallmark of AIDS. CCR5-dependent (R5) human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) isolates predominate in the early, asymptomatic stages of HIV-1 infection, while CXCR4-dependent (X4) isolates typically emerge at later stages, frequently coinciding with a rapid decline in CD4 T cells. Lymphocyte killing in vivo primarily occurs through apoptosis, but the importance of apoptosis of HIV-1-infected cells relative to apoptosis of uninfected bystander cells is controversial. Here we show that in human lymphoid tissues ex vivo, apoptosis of uninfected bystander CD4 T cells is a major mechanism of lymphocyte depletion caused by X4 HIV-1 strains but is only a minor mechanism of depletion by R5 strains. Further, X4 HIV-1-induced bystander apoptosis requires the interaction of the viral envelope glycoprotein gp120 with the CXCR4 coreceptor on CD4 T cells. These results emphasize the contribution of bystander apoptosis to HIV-1 cytotoxicity and suggest that in association with a coreceptor switch in HIV disease, T-cell killing evolves from an infection-restricted stage to generalized toxicity that involves a high degree of bystander apoptosis.
Gradual depletion of CD4 T cells is the hallmark of disease progression in AIDS (14). Both decreased thymic production and increased destruction of CD4 T cells are thought to play a role in CD4 depletion (25,37). In vivo and in vitro data have shown that CXCR4-dependent (X4) human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) strains cause more pronounced depletion of CD4 T cells than CCR5-dependent (R5) strains (11,23,24,29,32,33,41,44,45). The higher cytopathogenicity of X4 strains is due at least in part to their wider range of susceptible target cells (11,23,24,29,32,33,41,44,45). CXCR4 is expressed on nearly all CD4 T lymphocytes, whereas only about 15 to 30% express detectable levels of CCR5 on the cell surface (7, 23).Apoptosis of CD4 T cells has been proposed as a key mechanism underlying CD4 T-cell depletion in vivo (1, 34, 47), but the relative contributions of HIV-1-induced killing of productively infected cells as opposed to uninfected bystander cells remain highly controversial (8,15,17,27,39). To study HIV-1-induced cell death, we performed infections of ex vivo human lymphoid tissue cultures. This highly relevant system is permissive for HIV-1 infection independent of exogenous stimulation by mitogens or interleukin-2 and maintains its natural cytokine milieu, cellular activation status, and cell-to-cell interactions (19). Critically, these are all factors which have been shown to be crucial for the determination of HIV-1-induced cell death (10,21,26,30,35,42).We investigated the relative contributions of apoptosis in productively infected cells and apoptosis of uninfected bystander CD4 T cells to overall lymphocyte depletion. We observed massive HIV-1-induced apoptosis of bystander CD4 T cells following infections with X4 viruses but detected little bystander killing following infection with R5 vir...