Destined for Misperception? Status Dilemma and the Early Origin of US-China Antagonism

Abstract

Why did the US-China relations take a turn for worse around 2010 despite the bilateral efforts to forge a cooperative framework? Concerned about the danger of conflicts in the course of power transition-namely, the BThucydides Trap^-in US-China relations, scholars tend to see either a security dilemma at play or an intensification of status competition between an emerging power and the established hegemon. While recognizing the explanatory leverage of the security-dilemma framework and the status-competition model with regard to the continued deterioration of the US-China relations up to Trump, this article asserts that both models fall short in addressing the early origin of the deterioration of US-China relations. The concept Bstatus dilemmap romises to fill the analytic gap thereby left. The status dilemma suggests an inability of two states to grasp the status claims signaled from the other side. Misperceptions associated with status dilemmas fall outside of the purview of the security-dilemma framework, and could lead to the emergence of zero-sum competitions for status. Such misperceptions are apt to occur in a situation of power transition whereby status recognition tends to have geostrategic implications for the great powers involved. This article illustrates this logic of status dilemma via the US-China diplomacy over the Bcore interests.^This investigation promises crucial insights into the analogy of the Thucydides Trap to US-China relations. Keywords Misperceptions. Status dilemma. US-China relations. Core interests With the Trump administration escalating trade conflict with Beijing, breaking the US-China consensus on Taiwan's political status, and labeling China as a chief competitor, antagonisms in the US-China relations are hard to gloss over nowadays.

The Cold War analogy’s misrepresentation of the essence of US–China strategic competition

“…But it is safe to contend that these threat perceptions are misperceived, as they are motivated by fear and are not the results of objective assessments by each side. Accordingly, the US-China strategic competition largely originates from the low credibility of the cooperative signals sent by China, and further conflict is avoidable according to the logic of status conflict and power transition theories (Larson and Shevchenko 2019;Yoder 2019;Wang 2019).…”