Designing Successful Design Projects

Abstract

The importance of design is increasing in undergraduate engineering programs. Design is seen by proponents as a vital element of learning engineering. Compared to courses which focus on engineering analysis, design courses emphasize application of a broad spectrum of knowledge in narrow contexts. The importance of design courses is magnified by their impact on students and their disproportionate importance for assessment and accreditation. One element of design courses, particularly capstone courses, that has received little attention is how to characterize and choose suitable design projects.To better understand what aspects of design projects lead to successful capstone design experiences for students, six years of evaluation data on electrical engineering capstone design projects at a large, public research university were reviewed. Additionally, transcripts from four years of a capstone design course end-of-semester "after action review" by faculty, students, and teaching assistants were reviewed. From this work several characteristics of "successful" capstone projects emerged. While a definition of success is, of course, highly dependent on program specific outcomes, for this study success was defined as a project that was: judged by both students and faculty to have been completed successfully, allowed meaningful contributions by most students on a team, and satisfactorily met written and/or oral reporting requirements. Additionally, where available, comments from program graduates were used to identify successful projects.The specifics of projects varied widely, however several characteristics shared by successful capstone design efforts were identified. One characteristic included projects that were able to be repeated, or iterated, several times during the semester in which the project was given. A second characteristic of successful projects were that they did not fall to either extreme of the technology readiness level (TRL). The third characteristic is that projects did not draw on knowledge beyond which students had been exposed to or outside the discipline. These results provide some guidance on relatively simple ways to improve outcomes in capstone courses. Background: Capstone DesignDesign as an activity is increasing in importance in undergraduate engineering programs both due to ABET criteria and an overall recognition that engineering needs to be more hands-on 1 . Supporters view design as a necessary aspect of learning engineering that plays a unique and important role in the engineering degree program. As a results design is being introduced across the curriculum from freshman courses to the traditional capstone programs. The importance of design, particularly capstone, courses arises both from their purported impact on students and because of their disproportionate role in assessment and accreditation in many program 2 .Despite the importance of design courses to program outcomes, their format varies widely and outcomes are not standardized across programs. For the purposes of this paper des...

Toying With Engineering: Teaching Engineers to Be Entrepreneurial by Developing a Toy

“…Within engineering, design projects allow students to explore the underlying concepts guided by their individual interest and skills (Cheville, 2010; C. Wang, 2020). Open-ended projects use constraints to allow students to design or analyze real-world problems using the knowledge gained.…”

Evaluating Student Project Ranking in an Industry-Sponsored Multidisciplinary Capstone Program to Improve Student Placement and Project Proposals

“…There is a fair consensus amongst the faculty in the capstone design community that to attract students, projects must be cool in the sense of involving technology that is familiar to them and worthwhile [7], [8]. Two papers were found that asked students from capstone courses to evaluate the project selection process.…”

Students’ Preference for a Capstone Design Project: An Examination of the Impact of Accidental Competencies

“…al 3 . In their paper, they concluded that, although there are attributes that suggest a successful project 4 , finding a successful project remains an art rather than a recipe.…”