Design thinking in medical ethics education

Abstract

BackgroundDesign thinking (DT) is a tool for generating and exploring ideas from multiple stakeholders. We used DT principles to introduce students to the ethical implications of organ transplantation. Students applied DT principles to propose solutions to maximise social justice in liver transplant allocation.MethodsA 150 min interactive workshop was integrated into the longitudinal ethics curriculum. Following a group didactic on challenges of organ donation in the USA supplemented by patient stories, teams of students considered alternative solutions to optimise fairness of organ distribution and ethical implications of changing the current model. Facilitators led students through DT steps of empathy, defining the team’s point of view, ideating on potential solutions, prototyping a specific idea and testing the idea through oral presentation, with questions and answers by peers and faculty. The curriculum was evaluated with presurveys and postsurveys including quantitative and open-ended items.Results100 first year medical students participated. Before the session, 75.3% of students had no practical experience with DT. Following participation, students reported an increased understanding of the current liver transplant allocation system (p<0.01) and an increased appreciation of shortcomings of the current organ allocation system (p<0.01). After the session, 73.8% of students felt that DT could be used to approach complex health system problems.DiscussionStudents participating in a DT workshop displayed improved knowledge and attitudes toward organ transplantation and DT. In this pilot study, DT showed promise as a student-led approach emphasising collaboration and creativity in ethics curricula in medical education.

Reimagining the Rheumatology Fellowship Interview: Using Participatory Design‐Thinking Process to Create a More Applicant‐Centered Experience

“…As of June 2023, this represents the first known application of the design‐thinking process to address candidate selection in graduate medical education. Prior applications of design thinking in medical education include development of tools for care transitions, virtual health training, procedural simulations, and well‐being initiatives ( 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ). Because interviews are, by their nature, human‐centered, it was a natural decision to use such a quality improvement framework to better characterize the interview process and to identify areas for improvement.…”

Design Thinking in Medical Education: The Key Features and Practical Application

“…We have found that this approach not only increases the implementation of design thinking but also highlights the adaptable use of design thinking skills across different curricular themes. For example, design thinking has been successfully integrated into medical student ethics teaching about organ transplantation 27 and interprofessional learning about aging and disability. 28…”

The high-efficiency integration medical humanities and practice: the teaching reform in abdominocentesis

“…Medical ethics and humanities always are essential education for students to being a specialist in medicine, because professionalism is indispensable with scienti c, ethical and social 1,2 . Surely, medical students "must" include education regarding humanities theory and behavior in every medical college around the world 3 . Yet, discouragingly, it is often contradictory to combine medical professional knowledge with humanistic education within a limited learning time, along with the increase of learning tasks in many academic disciplines 4,5 .…”