“…For fairness, only the detection approaches that had used the same test set, i.e., the whole KDD'99 test set, are selected. As mentioned in Section 2, Three-tier IDS [16] can be classified as a hybrid approach based on misuse detection followed by anomaly detection; CSI-KNN [22] is a parallel hybrid approach; Multiple-level hybrid classifier [24], Multiple-level classifiers [25] and J48-BN [27] belong to layered approaches; and KDD'99 winner [29] and KDD'99 runner-up [30] are ensemble approaches. In Table 12, we list the reported results of the comparisons for the binary classes (normal and attack).…”