Design of Biomimetic Catalysts by Molecular Imprinting in Synthetic Polymers: The Role of Transition State Stabilization

Abstract

The impressive efficiency and selectivity of biological catalysts has engendered a long-standing effort to understand the details of enzyme action. It is widely accepted that enzymes accelerate reactions through their steric and electronic complementarity to the reactants in the rate-determining transition states. Thus, tight binding to the transition state of a reactant (rather than to the corresponding substrate) lowers the activation energy of the reaction, providing strong catalytic activity. Debates concerning the fundamentals of enzyme catalysis continue, however, and non-natural enzyme mimics offer important additional insight in this area. Molecular structures that mimic enzymes through the design of a predetermined binding site that stabilizes the transition state of a desired reaction are invaluable in this regard. Catalytic antibodies, which can be quite active when raised against stable transition state analogues of the corresponding reaction, represent particularly successful examples. Recently, synthetic chemistry has begun to match nature's ability to produce antibody-like binding sites with high affinities for the transition state. Thus, synthetic, molecularly imprinted polymers have been engineered to provide enzyme-like specificity and activity, and they now represent a powerful tool for creating highly efficient catalysts. In this Account, we review recent efforts to develop enzyme models through the concept of transition state stabilization. In particular, models for carboxypeptidase A were prepared through the molecular imprinting of synthetic polymers. On the basis of successful experiments with phosphonic esters as templates to arrange amidinium groups in the active site, the method was further improved by combining the concept of transition state stabilization with the introduction of special catalytic moieties, such as metal ions in a defined orientation in the active site. In this way, the imprinted polymers were able to provide both an electrostatic stabilization for the transition state through the amidinium group as well as a synergism of transition state recognition and metal ion catalysis. The result was an excellent catalyst for carbonate hydrolysis. These enzyme mimics represent the most active catalysts ever prepared through the molecular imprinting strategy. Their catalytic activity, catalytic efficiency, and catalytic proficiency clearly surpass those of the corresponding catalytic antibodies. The active structures in natural enzymes evolve within soluble proteins, typically by the refining of the folding of one polypeptide chain. To incorporate these characteristics into synthetic polymers, we used the concept of transition state stabilization to develop soluble, nanosized carboxypeptidase A models using a new polymerization method we term the "post-dilution polymerization method". With this methodology, we were able to prepare soluble, highly cross-linked, single-molecule nanoparticles. These particles have controlled molecular weights (39 kDa, for example) and, on average,...

A nature-inspired approach to reactor and catalysis engineering

“…In this way, NICE complements an ongoing revolution in bioinspired chemistry and materials science [2 ,3 ,4-6], which already sees applications in, for example, enzymemimics and antibody-mimics for catalysis [7][8][9][10] and in artificial photosynthesis [11 ,12 ,13-15]. These applications implement essential mechanistic steps of the biological model system at molecular and supramolecular scales.…”

“…These mechanisms include: (1) use of optimized, hierarchical networks to bridge scales, minimize transport limitations, and realize efficient, scalable solutions; (2) careful balancing of forces at one or more scales to achieve superior performance, for example, in terms of yield and selectivity; (3) emergence of complex functions from simple components, using dynamics as an organizing mechanism. Figure 1 presents an overview.In this way, NICE complements an ongoing revolution in bioinspired chemistry and materials science [2 ,3 ,4-6], which already sees applications in, for example, enzymemimics and antibody-mimics for catalysis [7][8][9][10] and in artificial photosynthesis [11 ,12 ,13-15]. These applications implement essential mechanistic steps of the biological model system at molecular and supramolecular scales.…”

Molecular imprinted photonic crystal for sensing of biomolecules

“…Since the idea of molecular imprinting was first put forward by Pauling in 1940s [43], over the past decades, it is well known that molecular imprinting is a very promising and rapidly evolving technology, with many possible applications such as preparative analytical separations [44][45], enzyme-like catalysis [46][47], solidphase extractions [48][49], chemical sensors [50][51] and drug delivery [52][53], etc. Molecular imprinting has proven to be particularly successful for small molecules.…”

Molecular Imprinted Silica with West Nile Antibody Templates show Specific and Selective Binding in Immunoassays

“…As monomers conform to the shape of the template, they are fixed by a rapid polymerization of the network, thus forming MIPs. Subsequent removal of the template leaves active sites in MIPs, capable of specifically recognizing the original template [9][10][11]. MIPs have the advantage of being stable at any temperature, can be stored dry for several years, and can be rapidly manufactured at any scale [12].…”