Describing Ultrasound Skills Teaching by Near-Peer and Faculty Tutors Using Cognitive Apprenticeship

Abstract

Phenomenon: Ultrasound skills are becoming increasingly important in clinical practice but are resource-intensive to teach. Near-peer tutors often alleviate faculty teaching burden, but little is known about what teaching methods near-peer and faculty tutors use. Using the lens of cognitive apprenticeship, this study describes how much time faculty and near-peer tutors spend on different teaching methods during abdominal ultrasound skills training. Approach: Sixteen near-peer and 16 faculty tutors were videotaped during one 55-min practical ultrasound lesson with randomly assigned students. Videos were directly coded using Cognitive Apprenticeship teaching methods and activities. Segment durations were summed up and compared quantitatively. Findings: All 32 tutors spent most of the time on observing and helping students (Coaching, Median 29:14 minutes), followed by asking open and stimulating questions (Articulation, 12:04 minutes and demonstrating and giving explanations (Modeling, 04:50 minutes). Overall, distributions of teaching methods used were similar between faculty and near-peer tutors. However, faculty tutors spent more time on helping students manually, whereas near-peer tutors spent more time on exploring students' learning gaps and establishing a safe learning climate. Cognitive Apprenticeship was well suited as observational framework to describe ultrasound skills. Insights: Ultrasound train-the-tutor programs should particularly focus on coaching and articulation. Near-peers' similar use of teaching methods adds to the evidence that supports the use of near-peer teaching in ultrasound skills education.

Building Consensus on the Point-of-Care Ultrasound Skills Required for Effective Healthcare Service Delivery at District Hospitals in South Africa: A Delphi Study

“…As shown in Table 2, only half of the participants received some accredited training, such as a postgraduate diploma and Foundation for Professional Development and EMSSA POCUS courses. The remaining half received noncredentialled POCUS or informal training, which should not come as a surprise, given that skill transfer is a common practice at the district hospital level and peer-to-peer POCUS education is practiced not only in South Africa, but across the world [48,49]. There was also lack of clarity on whether the institutions where the participants were based had access to sonographers, or if the participants were active POCUS trainers.…”

Development of a hybrid point-of-care ultrasound curriculum for first year medical students in a rural medical education program: a pilot study

“…A recent proposal suggested an instructor/student ratio of 1:4 to support learning during hands on scanning instruction [ 12 ]. While our rural program suffered from a lack of trained sonologists to support student skill development, a variety of suitable scanning instructors have been employed in various POCUS courses, including sonographers [ 37 , 47 , 48 ], anatomists [ 49 , 50 ], near-peer student teachers [ 20 , 51 ], self-led instruction [ 19 ], and physicians of various specialties [ 18 ]. Moreover, remote scanning guidance, such as the Butterfly IQ+ Teleguidance feature, emerged as a novel method to connect students to faculty support [ 52 ].…”

The urgent need to extend the appropriate use of ultrasound in Africa and worldwide. Overview, experiences and perspectives

“…After this experience, SUSME, the medical training company in ultrasound, was created in the United States. Its purpose is to identify the best way to teach ultrasound in US universities and for all specialists to annually update the guidelines for the correct use of ultrasound ( 19 ). This experience could be the meeting point between the global north and south regarding ultrasound in the introduction of such ultrasound programs in universities around the world.…”