Describing complex disease progression using joint latent class models for multivariate longitudinal markers and clinical endpoints

Abstract

Neurodegenerative diseases are characterized by numerous markers of progression and clinical endpoints. For instance, Multiple System Atrophy (MSA), a rare neurodegenerative synucleinopathy, is characterized by various combinations of progressive autonomic failure and motor dysfunction, and a very poor prognosis. Describing the progression of such complex and multi-dimensional diseases is particularly difficult. One has to simultaneously account for the assessment of multivariate markers over time, the occurrence of clinical endpoints, and a highly suspected heterogeneity between patients. Yet, such description is crucial for understanding the natural history of the disease, staging patients diagnosed with the disease, unraveling subphenotypes, and predicting the prognosis.Through the example of MSA progression, we show how a latent class approach can help describe complex disease progression measured by multiple repeated markers and clinical endpoints, and identify subphenotypes for exploring new pathological hypotheses. The joint latent class model includes class-specific multivariate mixed models to handle multivariate repeated biomarkers possibly summarized into latent dimensions and class-and-cause-specific proportional hazard models to handle time-to-event data. Maximum likelihood estimation is made available in the lcmm R package. In the French MSA cohort comprising data of 598 patients during up to 13 years, five subphenotypes of MSA were identified that differ by the sequence and shape of biomarkers degradation, and the associated risk of death. In posterior analyses, the five subphenotypes were used to explore the association between clinical progression and external imaging and fluid biomarkers, while properly accounting for the uncertainty in the subphenotypes membership.

Analysis of the 24-h activity cycle: An illustration examining the association with cognitive function in the Adult Changes in Thought study

“…How to account for both layers of uncertainty could be a direction of future research. Other approaches not considered here include functional principal components analysis of activity profiles measured by accelerometers ( Xu et al, 2019 ; Xiao et al, 2022 ) and latent class models of longitudinal biomarkers ( Proust-Lima et al, 2014 , 2022 ). A recent review of CoDA, also discusses other analytical approaches for compositional data, including advocating for alternative, simpler transformations to the ilr -transformation ( Greenacre et al, 2022 ).…”

Modelling the impact of protein-kinase R allelic variant on HIV biomarkers trajectories by means of latent class mixed models

“…In particular, we focus on the Integrated Classification Likelihood (ICL) criterion adopted when both model fitting and identification of natural groupings in the data are relevant for the analysis 31,32 . ICL criterion is defined as a combination of both the Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC) criterion and the posterior class membership and lower ICL values are associated with better model fit.…”