Depression in primary care: assessing suicide risk

Abstract

Major depression is a risk factor for suicide, accounting for up to 60% of suicides.(1-4) The literature has shown that a large proportion of patients who died by suicide had made contact with a primary care health provider within the three months preceding their deaths.(5-7) Patients who died by suicide were also more likely to visit their primary care practitioner than a psychiatrist.(6) This suggests that primary care practitioners are in a unique position to identify at-risk individuals and possibly intervene. (6,8,9) Primary care practitioners have been identified as one of the key potential gatekeepers in suicide prevention efforts.(10) Despite this, not all primary care practitioners routinely ask about suicide in depressed patients. WHAT CAN I DO IN MY PRACTICE?There are concerns that enquiring about suicide in patients who are depressed may trigger suicide, but evidence has shown this to be untrue. (12) Acknowledging and discussing suicide may reduce, instead of aggravate, suicidal ideation. Asking about suicide may help primary care physicians to identify high-risk patients who require urgent intervention (such as hospitalisation) and to uncover risk factors, some of which are amenable to intervention. (9) There are numerous tools to screen for suicide risk. One of the more widely used suicide assessment tools is the SAD PERSONS scale. This is a ten-item mnemonic, which was first developed as a tool for medical students and non-psychiatrist physicians to guide suicide risk assessment.(13) The use of the tool has been found to improve identification of persons with suicidal ideation. (14) The letters in the mnemonic represent demographic, behavioural and psychosocial risk factors for suicide (Box 1). Each risk factor that is present is accorded a score of 1 point, for a maximum of 10 points. Patterson et al recommended that: (a) patients with scores of 3-4 should be closely monitored; (b) hospitalisation should be strongly considered for those with scores of 5 and 6; and (c) patients with scores of 7-10 should be hospitalised for further assessment.(13) A systematic review of the performance of the SAD PERSONS scale in the clinical setting concluded that it did not acutely predict suicide behaviour. (15) Nonetheless, it is an easy scale to remember and use in the primary care setting.Information acquired via such assessment tools can add to the overall information obtained during a thorough suicide assessment. However, a systematic review concluded that there was insufficient evidence for the usefulness of suicide risk screening tools and that suicide assessment tools should not replace a thorough suicide assessment. (16) Each risk factor that is present is accorded a score of 1 point, for a maximum of 10 points.Patterson et al (13) recommended:• Close monitoring for patients with scores of 3 to 4• To strongly consider hospitalisation for those with scores of 5 and 6• Hospitalisation for further assessment for patients with scores of 7-10Note: Regardless of the score obtained, overall clinic...

Assessment of the Relationship of Depression With Tobacco and Caffeine Use Among University Students: A Cross-Sectional Study

“…In agreement with previous studies, most students in this study smoked as a coping mechanism for stress or family and social peer pressure [34][35][36]. Depression has catastrophic effects ranging from low quality of life to somatic symptoms and increased risk of suicide [37,38].…”

A Prospective Observational Study on Poisoning Cases in a Tertiary Care Hospital in Tamilnadu

“…28.5% of the participants suffered from depressive disorders. ~ 60% of suicidal attempts has been attributed to major depressive disorders, 14 because our study involves accidental and homicidal poisoning could explain the finding. Conflicts in family was another important etiology for suicide, intergeneration conflicts and explicit and veiled violence has been observed as important contributors to suicidal attempts.…”

“…94.3% (n=215) subjects got exposed at home, 3.9% (n=9) got exposed at remote area and 1.8% (n=4) got exposed at workplace. 84.6% (n=193) were suicidal attempts, 14 Common plant products utilized for poisoning were Abrus precatorius (4.4%, n=10) and Thevetia peruviana (2.2%, n=5). Paracetamol was the most commonly used (3.5%, n=8) NSAID followed by diclofenac (0.9%, n=2), acyclofenac (0.4%, n=1), paracetamol diclofenac combination (0.4%, n=1) and paracetamol acyclofenac combination (0.4%, n=1).…”

The Patient with Depression: Assessment and Management

“…One of the tools used to assess suicide risk is the SAD PERSONS Scale. 14 is is a ten-item mnemonic with a maximum score of ten points. Close monitoring of patients is needed for scores of three to four; strongly consider hospitalisation for those with scores of ve and six; and hospitalisation for further assessment for patients with scores of seven to ten.…”