Depicting estimates using the intercept in meta‐regression models: The moving constant technique

Abstract

In any scientific discipline, the ability to portray research patterns graphically often aids greatly in interpreting a phenomenon. In part to depict phenomena, the statistics and capabilities of meta-analytic models have grown increasingly sophisticated. Accordingly, this article details how to move the constant in weighted meta-analysis regression models (viz. “meta-regression”) in order to illuminate the patterns in such models across a range of complexities. Although it is commonly ignored in practice, the constant (or intercept) in such models can be indispensible when it is not relegated to its usual static role. The moving constant technique makes possible estimates and confidence intervals at moderator levels of interest as well as continuous confidence bands around the meta-regression line itself. Such estimates, in turn, can be highly informative to interpret the nature of the phenomenon being studied in the meta-analysis, especially when a comparison to an absolute or a practical criterion is the goal. Knowing the point at which effect size estimates reach statistical significance or other practical criteria of effect size magnitude can be quite important. Examples ranging from simple to complex models illustrate these principles. Limitations and extensions of the strategy are discussed.

Single-Session Behavioral Interventions for Sexual Risk Reduction: A Meta-Analysis

“…These techniques all represented concrete skills that were taught in the interventions and as a result were categorized as behavioral skills components. These moderator variables were entered into a series of weighted least squares regression models incorporating random-effects assumptions (33), and used the moving constant technique to produce estimates at meaningful levels of the moderators (37). The regression models were weighted least square regressions weighted by the inverse of the variable.…”

HIV prevention interventions to reduce sexual risk for African Americans: The influence of community-level stigma and psychological processes

“…To reduce multicollinearity, continuous moderators were mean centered before constructing interaction terms or examining multiple moderators simultaneously. Predicted estimates of effect size means and confidence intervals at different levels of moderators of interest were probed using the moving-constant technique (Johnson & Huedo-Medina, 2011). Analyses were conducted in Stata 11.2 (StataCorp, 2009).…”

Behavioural interventions to reduce sexual risk for HIV in heterosexual couples: a meta-analysis

“…Moderators of ES magnitude were examined using modified weighted least squares regression analysis with weights equivalent to the inverse of the variance. The moving constant technique was used to estimate mean ES (d + ) and 95% CIs at specific moderator levels of interest 45. To test for potential reporting bias, asymmetries in the distribution of ES outcomes were examined using Begg's technique,46 trim and fill,47 and Egger's technique 48…”