Demand-side broadband policy in the context of digital transformation: An examination of SME digital advisory policies in Wales

Abstract

Increasing attention has been paid to the potential for demand-side policies to stimulate use of broadband networks. Such policies form part of the increasing digitalisation of the economy and wider society. This is an area where governments are also facing challenges in their efforts to maximise the efficiency and effectiveness of their policies. The paper sheds light on the impact that the transition towards digital has had on demand-side policies supporting the adoption of broadband and digital technologies by SMEs, and draws out the implications for policy, using a case study of Wales in the UK over a ten-year period. It shows that digitalisation has seen policy mechanisms and messages evolving as policy makers have created a more integrated and multi-channel approach to the delivery of advisory support to SMEs, but that the emergence of multiple types of actors (large digital platform businesses) and ongoing digitalisation are adding complexity to policies and their interaction with other forms of public and private business support.

Working from Home and Digital Divides: Resilience during the Pandemic

“…Although the long-term effects of such drastic changes in telecommuting and attitudes toward working from home are difficult to predict, the reliability of home broadband services deserves more consideration than in the past. This would represent a switch from previous demand-side broadband policies in the United Kingdom, which tended to be aimed at supporting small and medium enterprises (Henderson 2020). Such policies were based on previous research regarding the productivity effects of broadband infrastructure (DeStefano, Kneller, and Timmis 2018).…”

The Regional Consequences of New Digital Infrastructure: Can Welsh Smes Gain an Edge From Access and Adoption of Superfast Broadband?

“…Here, there are signs that private sector actors are complementing (or perhaps displacing) government intervention. For example, this can be in the form of introducing online and face-to-face support for SMEs in the area of digital technologies (e.g., Amazon Academy, Google Digital Garage and Facebook Business) and this may be an opportunity for public and private sectors to work together in supporting digital skills among the SME base in Wales and other regions (Henderson, 2020).…”

Together we are strong? A systematic literature review on how SMEs use relation-based collaboration to operate in rural areas

“…With regard to the spatial perspective, government can improve the situation of rural areas through dedicated investments into enhanced broadband connectivity (Briglauer et al 2019). With regard to the enterprise perspective, government can implement demand-side policies in terms of capability formation such as skill development, advisory, knowledge exchange (R€ ais€ anen and Tuovinen 2020), incentive provision (e.g., financial support) or regulation such as the mandatory platform use for business SME users (Henderson 2020).…”

“…In addition to public actors, there are other potential collaboration partners regarding digitalization in rural areas. In a case study on Welsh rural SMEs, Henderson (2020) found that non-government actors emerge as important providers of digital support. These potential collaboration partners include Google Garage or Amazon Academy where global digital firms cooperate with local and regional support structures.…”