Delivering Public Services: Locality, Learning and Reciprocity in Place Based Practice

Abstract

Policymakers across myriad jurisdictions are grappling with the challenge of complex policy problems. Multi‐faceted, complex, and seemingly intractable, ‘wicked’ problems have exhausted the repertoire of the standard policy approaches. In response, governments are increasingly looking for new options, and one approach that has gained significant scholarly interest, along with increasing attention from practitioners, is ‘place‐based’ solutions. This paper surveys conceptual aspects of this approach. It describes practices in comparable jurisdictions – the United Kingdom, the EU, and the United States. And it explores efforts over the past decade to ‘localise’ Indigenous services. It sketches the governance challenge in migrating from top‐down or principal‐agent arrangements towards place‐based practice. The paper concludes that many of the building blocks for this shift already exist but that these need to be re‐oriented around ‘learning’. Funding and other administrative protocols may also ultimately need to be redefined.

Enhancing Learning in Emergency Services Organisational Work

“…Public service organisations of all types currently grapple with complex and ‘wicked’ problems (Marsh et al. ) none more so than those agencies responsible for emergency response to natural disasters. Over the past decade there has been increasing scrutiny on these organisations, often linked to disaster preparedness and response, with the results usually characterised as policy failure (see, e.g.…”

South West Food Community: how government and community initiatives are supporting systemic change towards enhanced food security

“…The approach also included a more detailed assessment of initiatives against identified desirable attributes for change, which is a current gap in the evidence base. This project used a place‐based approach, which enabled fine‐grain local‐level assessment of food security projects 14 . Limitations included a small sample, reducing the generalisability of these findings.…”

“…Such functioning could be understood through a Systemic Innovation Lab approach 13 and this methodology possesses features identified as important to address complex wicked problems 13 . For example, this approach is place‐based, meaning that the focus is at a ‘fine grain local level’, which helps to remove some of the ‘wickedness’ of the complex problem 14 . The approach includes bringing together a range of collaborators and a system of initiatives working to address the problem and advocates that governments should recognise its role as an enabler of change 13 .…”

“…13 For example, this approach is place-based, meaning that the focus is at a 'fine grain local level' , which helps to remove some of the 'wickedness' of the complex problem. 14 The approach includes bringing together a range of collaborators and a system of initiatives working to address the problem and advocates that governments…”

Fair Facility Allocation in Emergency Service System

“…The problems that have to be solved are multifaceted, complex, and seemingly insoluble. That's a way the policymakers are increasingly looking for new options (Marsh et al, 2017;Koval et al, 2019). The three primary emergency services that can be summoned directly by the public are emergency medical services, fire-fighters, and police.…”