Delirium, in 405 articles of medical (non-surgical or ICU) inpatients: unproven speed of onset and recovery

Abstract

PurposeThere is agreement in the medical literature that delirium is of sudden or rapid onset. Although the speed of recovery cannot be used for initial diagnosis, recovery speed provides a test of diagnostic criteria. The aim of this study was to determine whether articles on delirium among medical inpatients proved sudden onset and rapid recovery.MethodsThe literature was searched for studies with at least 50 patients on medical or geriatric wards. Excluded were postoperative, critical care, and nursing home studies. Speed of onset was extracted as either the interval between symptom onset and diagnosis or between hospital admission and diagnosis of incident delirium. Mean or median days to recovery from delirium and the scale used to measure recovery were identified.ResultsFour-hundred and five articles were analyzed with 789,709 patients. The median article had 220 patients. Onset could only be extracted in 11 articles (2.7%): mean onset was 3.09±2.38 days. Median onset was 3.0 days, which conforms to Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-V). Only 56 of 405 articles (13.8%) reported timing of recovery but mean or median recovery was available in 25 of 405 (6.2%): 6.56±4.80 days.ConclusionMedical delirium articles have failed to establish rapid onset and rapid recovery.

Delirium in a surgical context from a nursing perspective: A hybrid concept analysis

“…The speed of onset of delirium was defined as the interval in days between the last normal cognitive day and symptom/sign onset, or symptom and sign onset to diagnosis. Regal, 2017 . Prevalent Delirium is detected at admission or time of enrolment (for study purposes) Ciampi et al., 2017 ; Mistraletti et al., 2012 .…”

“…(For study purposes) Adamis et al., 2015 . Regal, 2017 . Resolving resolving delirium (initially full syndromal delirium becoming subsyndromal delirium over time) Leonard et al., 2014 ; Meagher et al., 2012a .…”

Predicting the Onset of Delirium on Hourly Basis in an Intensive Care Unit Following Cardiac Surgery

“…[8] In this study, CAM-ICU classification is used to formally diagnose delirium (similarly to many other delirium prediction studies [9]. The onset of delirium can occur within hours [10], and rapid diagnosis is critical if the condition is to be successfully reversed, and mortality avoided [11]. CAM-ICU assessments are usually administered fairly infrequently (approx.…”