Deliberative and Affective Risky Decisions in Teenagers: Different Associations with Maladaptive Psychological Functioning and Difficulties in Emotion Regulation?

Abstract

Using network analysis, we investigated the relationships between maladaptive psychological functioning, difficulties in emotion regulation, and risk-taking in deliberative and affective behavioral decisions. Participants (103 adolescents aged between 13 and 19 years, 62% boys) took the Cold (deliberative) and Hot (affective) versions of the Columbia Card Task and completed the Youth Self-Report (YSR) and the Difficulties in Emotion Regulation Scale (DERS). In contrast to the view that risk propensity increases from preadolescence to middle adolescence and decreases at later ages, our study revealed no age-specific trend. YSR syndrome scales were significantly correlated with risk propensity, but only in the Cold version. The YSR Thought Problems scale was the most central node in the network, linking internalizing and externalizing problems with risk propensity in the Cold CCT. Lack of emotional Clarity was the only DERS consistently linked with risk-taking both in correlation and network analyses. Maladaptive psychological functioning and difficulties in emotion regulation were linked with risk propensity in affective risky decisions through deliberative processes. The statistical significance of direct and indirect effects was further examined using nonparametric mediation analyses. Our study highlights the role of cognitive factors that in each variable set might account for risk-taking in teenagers.

The Risk-Taking and Self-Harm Inventory for Adolescents: Validation of the Italian Version (RTSHIA-I)

“…In contrast, cognitive regulation plays a role in RT as it is common to observe failures of executive function skills, such as inhibition, planning, and maintaining attention when youth engage in reckless behaviors [ 11 ]. Lauriola and colleagues [ 12 ] also assume that affective risky decisions—decisions in an affective context where emotions are at play—are influenced by a cognitive limitation in understanding and labeling emotions, as well as maladaptive psychological functioning.…”

Daring and Distress: Insights on Adolescent Risk Taking and Difficulties in Emotion Regulation from a Network Analysis Perspective

“…A portion of the sample in this study participated in cognitive tasks on separate occasions as part of a different research investigation. The outcomes and findings from that specific study have been published elsewhere [ 49 ]. Before recruitment, a psychologist introduced this study’s general aim to the school principal and parents.…”