Defining sustainability? Insights from a small village in Bosnia and Herzegovina

Abstract

The term ''sustainability'' is flexible as it needs to function in many different contexts and across many issues. At the same time, this flexibility makes it difficult to assess and easy to misuse. Over the last three decades, numerous sustainability assessment tools have been developed to better define the term. In this paper, we critically address these attempts and argue that the flexibility of the term is not solely problematic, but allow people to create their own sustainability imaginaries, by which we mean a society's understanding of how environmental resources should be used. We show this through a case study, the Martin Brod village in Bosnia and Herzegovina, where, within a few years, the inhabitants changed their sustainability imaginaries in parallel with shifting external socio-economic conditions and expectations. We primarily applied qualitative research methods. Our results show that changing sustainability imaginaries was made possible due to the flexibility of the term which enabled otherwise disempowered local inhabitants to have agency. Consequently, a stricter definition of sustainability may have unintended consequences for people struggling to maintain a political voice in settings such as Bosnia and Herzegovina.

Tourism Persistence in the Southeastern European Countries: The Impact of COVID-19

“…On the whole the COVID-19 pandemic had a severe impact on the number of foreign tourist arrivals and overnight stays in the SEE countries, which raises the issue of adopting appropriate policy responses. A relevant debate, which predates the crisis, concerns how to develop a sustainable tourism system that might be less vulnerable to such exogenous shocks; for instance, in the case of Martin Brod, a small town in Bosnia and Herzegovina, within a couple of years the locals changed their sustainability imaginaries ("a society's understanding of how environmental resources should be used") in response to shifting external financial circumstances (Dogmus & Nielsen, 2021).…”

Sustainability paralysis in travel consumption: A Reddit study

“…Other scholars view the mutability of the concept not as a weakness, but as one of its strengths (Farley and Smith, 2020) and encourage researchers to think “creatively” about sustainability. These conversations have fostered the emergence of new models, interpretations and reinterpretations (Dogmus and Nielsen, 2021; Moore et al, 2017; Ramsey, 2015).…”