Defining Economic Injury Levels for Sea Lamprey Control in the Great Lakes Basin

Abstract

We estimated economic injury levels (EILs) and associated optimal control budgets for sea lamprey Petromyzon marinus for each of the Great Lakes using common assumptions and consistent methods. The lake‐specific EILs are defined as equilibrium sea lamprey abundances below which incremental increases in control expenditures do not pay for themselves in terms of benefits (in the form of increased harvest of desired host species). We assume that sea lamprey control efforts result in an increase in the availability of adult hosts for fishery harvest, which provides economic value to society. We used a stochastic population model to simulate the sea lamprey life cycle as well as management actions (e.g., treatment of streams with lampricide) over a range of potential control budgets. Prior to running simulations, the model was calibrated for each Great Lake so that resulting forecasts were consistent with recent observed adult (spawning‐phase) sea lamprey abundance levels given recent control budgets. Our calculated EILs suggest that sea lamprey abundances lower than those currently observed or those specified by interim damage targets are justifiable and may be obtainable with increases in control budgets (roughly 25% to 55% per lake). This conclusion is robust to a range of plausible assumptions about the economic benefits attributable to host fish. Received January 21, 2011; accepted April 9, 2012

Lampreys: Biology, Conservation and Control

“…Actual larval survival rates are highly uncertain, but some estimates are available. These estimates are somewhat higher than the values (39.5-51.8 %) used in sea lamprey population model simulations Irwin et al 2012), but are generally lower than those (52-96 %) reported by from cage studies in which predators would have been excluded. Weise and Pajos (1998) estimated annual survival of one age class of sea lamprey larvae to be 61 % (see below).…”

Rapid evolution meets invasive species control: the potential for pesticide resistance in sea lamprey

“…First, we calibrated the model for each Great Lake by adjusting larval natural mortality rates such that recent observed adult sea lamprey abundance levels were forecasted, on average, when recent levels of lampricide control were applied (c.f. Irwin et al 2012). Second, we ran simulations for each lake with no lampricide control applied, to estimate population abundances associated with no control.…”

Management Strategy Evaluation of Pheromone‐baited Trapping Techniques to Improve Management of Invasive Sea Lamprey

“…The model includes uncertainty in biological processes (recruitment and growth), assessment of larval abundance in reaches considered for treatment, and implementation of lampricide control. This model was successfully applied to evaluate allocation of budgetary resources between larval population assessment and other management actions ), conduct a preliminary assessment of integrated control strategies (i.e., lampricide and alternative control [specifically adult-targeted alternative control]; Dawson [2007]), and generate estimates of economic injury levels (Szlai et al [2005], Irwin et al [2012]).…”