Defining a ‘maturity model’ in the construction context: A systematic review

Abstract

A maturity model is critical in analysing an entity as it evaluates the current situation and provides insights on enhancing the capabilities to reach higher maturity. Maturity models are being used in many industries and proven to have a positive impact on organisational development. Definition of a context specific maturity model is vital as it brings clarity to the model identification and better understanding relevant for a respective industry. Even though several construction maturity models exist, a clear and a comprehensive definition is not noticeable. A comprehensive definition for maturity models in construction sector would assist industry stakeholders to understand the components and key areas of construction maturity. Consequently, it would provide accurate and impactful results for construction firms to achieve higher maturity levels. Thus, the main aim of this paper is to establish a new definition for construction maturity models. In the process, the methodology included a systematic literature review adopting PRISMA literature review method and a content analysis using thematic analysis. The study analysed fifteen construction maturity models and identified nine overarching themes which were fundamental in developing the definition. The proposed definition would facilitate a better understanding among end users of construction maturity models, and it would assist the readers to distinguish it from other various models. Therefore, the derived definition would promote application of the concept of construction maturity in the industry. Further research could be conducted for diverse types of construction to enhance the effectiveness of the maturity models.

Developing a definition for lean construction maturity models through a PRISMA systematic literature review

“…A well-established definition of LCMMs contributes to the advancement of knowledge and theory in the field of LC. It provides a foundation for further research and investigation into the effectiveness and applicability of MMs, facilitating the development of more refined models and frameworks that address the unique challenges and requirements of the construction industry (Jayanetti et al, 2022). Similarly, the developed model facilitates benchmarking and performance measurement, enabling organizations to identify their current position, set goals, and track progress over time.…”

A Systematic Review of Polluting Processes Produced by the Textile Industry and Proposals for Abatement Methods

“…Finally, the PRISMA statement using a flow diagram was elaborated, which is a relevant method for analyzing a systematic review and that guarantees the transparency of an investigation since it helps to select the appropriate studies based on specific criteria, both inclusion and exclusion, for developing https://doi.org/10.31881/TLR.2023.165 a research topic, of interest and then analyze and review the results obtained. While this method is used in systematic reviews focused on the health sector, it currently applies to any research [27,28].…”

Digital Transformation of Building Permits: Current Status, Maturity, and Future Prospects

“…Ref. [38] focuses on the study of the construction maturity models by establishing a new definition that would facilitate a better understanding among end users in the construction industry. Refs.…”