Defensive Avoidance of Disapproval: The Relationship of a Defensive Style to Physical and Mental Health

Abstract

This article presents an exploration of a clinically meaningful interpersonal style labeled here as defensive avoidance of disapproval (DAD), which involves a motivated inattention to physiological, affective, or cognitive reactions arising from stressful social transactions, thereby safeguarding a self-image of social competence. First, we discuss conceptual antecedents of DAD derived from post-Freudian theories of twentieth-century psychodynamic and interpersonally oriented clinicians. Second, we highlight measurement issues as they relate to DAD. Third, we review research on the association of DAD with psychophysiological stress reactivity and diminished health. Finally, DAD-related clinical implications are considered. Our discussion of DAD invites the (1) assessment of phenomenological "blind spots" regarding the physiological, affective, and cognitive components of disapproval-induced stress, (2) development of strategies to decrease premature therapy termination that may result from a defensive avoidance of social disapproval, and (3) cultivation of interventions to increase the high DAD patient's acknowledgement, rather than rejection, of the signs of social stress.

Ethnicity, Cortisol, and Experimental Pain Responses Among Persons With Symptomatic Knee Osteoarthritis

“…However, findings are mixed. For example, acknowledging the presence of discrimination may be necessary to effectively cope and adjust to discrimination (31), and underreporting perceived racial discrimination may be related to avoidance, denial, and suppression (32), which has been linked to several negative health outcomes (33). An fMRI study found that attributing social exclusion to racial discrimination during a simulated, interactive laboratory game was associated with reduced activation in neural areas related to distress and increased activation in neural areas related to emotion regulation (34).…”

Differential effects of perceived discrimination on the diurnal cortisol rhythm of African Americans and Whites

“…Furthermore, evidence suggests that because instances of racial discrimination are likely to be occurring on a regular basis for members of stigmatized groups, acknowledging the presence of discrimination may be necessary for effective coping and adjustment (Major et al, 2002). On the other hand, a lack of reported discrimination may be indicative of avoidance, denial, or suppression which has been associated with a host of negative health outcomes (Jorgensen and Thibodeau, 2007). Therefore, although members of stigmatized minority groups would be expected to show poorer overall physical health outcomes (due to institutional barriers and greater exposure to daily discrimination), one would not necessarily expect minority individuals who report more discrimination to have worse health as compared to those who report little or no discrimination.…”

Detection and monitoring of early dental caries and erosion using three-dimensional enhanced truncated-correlation photothermal coherence tomography imaging

“…Dental caries is the most prevalent disease in humans. 1,2 It is estimated that up to 90% of schoolaged children and almost 100% of adults suffer from dental decay of varying severity at some point in their lives. 3 Furthermore, the high consumption of sugar and acid-rich snacks and drinks in the modern western lifestyle can be traced to be the primary cause of dental demineralization and erosion, 4 in particular for youth.…”