“…For example, Mueller and Atesoglu (1993), Macnair et al (1995), Tahir (1995), Brumm (1997) and Murdoch et al (1997) provide evidence supporting the Benoit Hypothesis. However, Biswas and Ram (1986), Alexander and Robert (1990), Kinsella (1990), Mintz (1990, 1991), and Payne and Ross (1992) could not find a statistically significant relationship between defence expenditures and economic growth. Smith (1980), Deger and Sen (1983), Deger and Smith (1983), Lim (1983), Cappelen et al (1984), Faini et al (1984), Lipow and Antinori (1995), Blomberg (1996), Vougas (1999), De Rouen (2000), and Abu-Bader and Abu-Qarn (2003) argue that the effect of defence expenditures on economic growth is negative, due to crowding-out effects.…”