“…Experimentally determined thermal activation energies are quite low 30-60 meV [3,4,5] compared to theoretical first principles calculations. These calculations [26,27], however, do not completely agree on the nature of the dominant defects and the level positions they introduce in the CZTS band gap. There seems to be a consensus that Cu Zn antisites (E a ≈ 120 meV [26], 220 meV [27]) and copper vacancies (V Cu , E a ≈ 20 meV [26], 70 meV [27]) are the dominant acceptor type defects, and that Zn Cu antisites (E a ≈ 150 meV [26], 70 meV [27]) and Cu interstitials (Cu i , E a ≈ 150 meV [26], 50 meV [27]) form rather shallow donors.…”