The enhancement of lepton flavor violation rates due to Z-penguins observed in Ref.[1] was a consequence of an error in the literature. Correcting this error, the effect is gone.We found in Ref.[1] that Z-penguins can cause very large contributions to the lepton flavor violating 3-body decays €i -* 3€j in many extensions of the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM). The effect was induced by the presence of large flavor violating superpotential terms, like in the case of the supersymmetric (SUSY) version of the inverse seesaw. In particular, it came from chargino contributions to the form factor FL, defined asOur calculation of FL in the context of the SUSY inverse seesaw was based on the analytical results obtained in Refs. [2,3] for the MSSM. Using these references, one finds that the chargino contributions to FL are given bywhere CfAX, ER BA'L{c), Q \Y, and Z { [ ] are involved couplings and C0, B u and C24 are loop functions. The crucial loop function is C24, which can be found to be 4C24(mg, m], ml) = B0{m\, mj) + mlC0(m l, m\ , m\) (3) when combining the definitions in Refs. [2,3], However, it was recently found in Ref. [4] that C24 is related to C00, defined by DCooiml, m], m\) = B0(m\, m\) + m §C0(m^, m \, m \),where D = 4 -2e in dimensional regularization, via C24 = C00~g-The difference between Eqs. (5) and (3) is the constant The result of Ref.[4] has been confirmed by the authors of Refs. [2,3] in Ref. [5]. While the impact of this constant is negligible in high-scale seesaw models, it changes the conclusion for low-scale seesaw models: the leading order term to F^ 1 which caused the enhancement between Z-and /-penguins cancels exactly. Thus, the Z-penguins usually do not dominate over the photonic penguins. The consequence of this correction in the inverse seesaw was discussed in detail in Ref. [6]. It was found that, in low-scale seesaw models, the constraints from lepton flavor violating 3-body decays can still be stronger than those from radiative decays. However, the relative enhancement does not come from SUSY Z-penguins with charginos in the loop, but from non-SUSY box diagrams with light right-handed neutrinos. This agrees with the results independently found in Ref. [7]. Furthermore, the same outcome applies to lepton flavor violation in R-parity violating models: the Z-penguin contributions to -> 3*? • are usually smaller than the photon penguins and the constraints from Br(Z, -> €ff) are more severe than those from Br(tf,--*■ 3t?j).1550-7998/2015/91(5)/059902 (2) 059902-1