Decision making and cultural heritage: An application of the Multi-Attribute Value Theory for the reuse of historical buildings

Ferretti, Valentina; Bottero, Marta; Mondini, Giulio

doi:10.1016/j.culher.2013.12.007

Cited by 183 publications

(114 citation statements)

References 31 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…The method can be used for once-off decisions (Ferretti et al, 2014). It is the most comprehensive MCDA method and the most detailed way to investigate the internal structure of mining corporations, as a preference function is created for each criterion.…”

Section: ® Measuring Attractiveness By the Categorical-based Evaluatimentioning

confidence: 99%

A mining perspective on the potential of renewable electricity sources for operations in South Africa: Part 2 - A multi-criteria decision assessment

Votteler

Brent

2017

J. South. Afr. Inst. Min. Metall.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Recent developments in the macroeconomic environment necessitate an investigation of the internal structure of mining corporations to evaluate possible alternative electricitygenerating sources (Roehrl and Riahi, 2000). To be able to combine current knowledge of macroeconomic factors and the internal structure of mining corporations, the research process is presented in two papers. The first paper (Votteler and Brent, 2016) investigated the internal structure and argued that a strategic tool should be used to evaluate electricity sources from the perspective of mining corporations. The multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) approach was selected as the most appropriate strategic tool. Based on a literature review of previous similar MCDA approaches in energy planning, it was concluded that no adaptation of MCDA methods could be found from a corporate, mining, or South African perspective. Finally, the paper investigated the internal evaluation structure in collaboration with mining corporations, by identifying the criteria they use to evaluate electricity sources.In this second paper we set out to identify the best MCDA method to investigate a potential fit for renewable energy sources at mining operations. We then implement the selected MCDA method. Previous macroeconomic research identified non-gridconnected solar PV, onshore wind, and geothermal power in hybrid versions along with the current on-site diesel generators and grid connection to Eskom as the most lucrative. The choice of these hybrid versions is based on the constant electricity demand of mining operations and the intermittency of the renewables. The business model identified was self-generation via own investment (Votteler and Brent, 2016). The first paper describes the evaluation criteria used by mining corporations to determine this choice. All further information for implementing the MAVT method was gathered in cooperation with mining corporations and renewable and conventional energy companies in order to use real-time data.The purpose of this paper is to analyse and compare the strengths and weaknesses of these potential electricity sources, according to a possible fit to the specific needs of mining corporations and from their perspective. To optimize the learning process for mining corporations in order to equip them with an understanding of renewable energy technologies and for energy companies to learn A mining perspective on the potential of renewable electricity sources for operations in South Africa: Multi-criteria decision analysis, multi-attribute value theory, renewable electrical energy.

show abstract

Section: ® Measuring Attractiveness By the Categorical-based Evaluatimentioning

confidence: 99%

A mining perspective on the potential of renewable electricity sources for operations in South Africa: Part 2 - A multi-criteria decision assessment

Votteler

Brent

2017

J. South. Afr. Inst. Min. Metall.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Criteria eventually in conflict-that create awareness about conservative interventions-can be also identified. Particular methodological approaches were: maturity matrix assessment [48], multi-attribute value theory (MAVT) [42], methodology for energy-efficient building refurbishment (MEEBR) [25], the functionality index [39], or other methods that require the use of computer simulation or numerical methods. This diversity and heterogeneity of tools shows the importance of using cross-disciplinary, multi-criteria, multi-index, multi-level procedures to develop an effective method/tool able to plan and assess different levels of sustainable interventions depending on the conservation needs, type of building, and climate conditions.…”

Section: Methodological Contributionsmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…From the analysis, 14 documents (54%) describe methods referred to a low level of interventions i.e., preservation (e.g., [35,36]) and conservation (e.g., [37,38]) using the rule of minimum intervention and as much as possible non-destructive techniques. Five publications (19%) have as a primary driver mid-level interventions (i.e., refurbishment, rehabilitation) (e.g., [39][40][41]) while seven documents (27%) present methodological approaches applied to deeper interventions and the full restoration of decayed or abandoned buildings (e.g., [42][43][44][45] proves the importance, both in the heritage and sustainable sector, of keeping decision makers, owners, and local communities involved in HB conservation projects. Concern about the social aspect from the beginning may positively influence the planning of the interventions (i.e., maintenance, preservation, and refurbishment/restoration), as well as guarantee the long-lasting and effective application of advice coming from the research community.…”

Section: Methodological Contributionsmentioning

confidence: 99%

Towards Zero-Emission Refurbishment of Historic Buildings: A Literature Review

Loli

Bertolin

2018

Buildings

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Nowadays, restoration interventions that aim for minimum environmental impact are conceived for recent buildings. Greenhouse gas emissions are reduced using criteria met within a life-cycle analysis, while energy saving is achieved with cost-effective retrofitting actions that secure higher benefits in terms of comfort. However, conservation, restoration and retrofitting interventions in historic buildings do not have the same objectives as in modern buildings. Additional requirements have to be followed, such as the use of materials compatible with the original and the preservation of authenticity to ensure historic, artistic, cultural and social values over time. The paper presents a systematic review-at the intersection between environmental sustainability and conservation-of the state of the art of current methodological approaches applied in the sustainable refurbishment of historic buildings. It identifies research gaps in the field and highlights the paradox seen in the Scandinavian countries that are models in applying environmentally sustainable policies but still poor in integrating preservation issues.

show abstract

“…Decision-making process in view of cultural heritage's management is a multi-complex procedure [3], especially since restricted resource allocation is involved. Social attitudes at architectural heritage are highly important when funding is part of public expenses.…”

mentioning

confidence: 99%

The social aspects of rural, mountainous built environment. Key elements of a regional policy planning

Giannakopoulou

Kaliampakos

2016

Journal of Cultural Heritage

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Decision making and cultural heritage: An application of the Multi-Attribute Value Theory for the reuse of historical buildings

Cited by 183 publications

References 31 publications

A mining perspective on the potential of renewable electricity sources for operations in South Africa: Part 2 - A multi-criteria decision assessment

A mining perspective on the potential of renewable electricity sources for operations in South Africa: Part 2 - A multi-criteria decision assessment

Towards Zero-Emission Refurbishment of Historic Buildings: A Literature Review

The social aspects of rural, mountainous built environment. Key elements of a regional policy planning

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About