Debunking Political Disinformation through Journalists’ Perceptions: An Analysis of Colombia’s Fact-Checking News Practices

Abstract

Fact-checking alliances emerged worldwide to debunk political disinformation in electoral contexts because of social concerns related to information authenticity. This study, thus, included the Latin American context in fact-checking journalism studies as a journalistic practice to fight political disinformation. Through analyzing RedCheq, the first fact-checking journalism alliance in an electoral regional context led by Colombiacheck, 11 in-depth interviews were conducted to identify the perceptions of regional fact-checkers regarding the usefulness of this journalistic practice, its achievements, and the key aspects for incorporating fact-checking into the regional media ecosystem. The study results revealed that RedCheq achieved the goal of fighting disinformation, and that fact-checking developed as transformational leverage for the regional media. Regional journalists perceived fact-checking as an element that restores credibility and social trust in regional media as the epistemology of this journalistic practice neglects the power pressure and dissemination of official narratives. Finally, this study highlighted how fact-checking journalism contributes to the democratic quality and civic empowerment in silenced and polarized environments. In addition, it discussed the need to expand fact-checking journalism’s coverage to new geographical areas and improve journalists’ professional competencies and training, thereby enabling them to function as using verification tools based on regional journalists’ requirements.

Testing the Efficacy of Attitudinal Inoculation Videos to Enhance COVID-19 Vaccine Acceptance: Quasi-Experimental Intervention Trial

“…Currently, the most common approach to countering misinformation is to engage in fact checking. Research evaluating the utility of online fact checking suggests that even under less uncertain conditions, it remains an uneven but relatively effective counterstrategy to disinformation [ 22 - 26 ]. However, fact checking carries with it 2 challenges: asymmetry and volume.…”

Communities of practice in the production and resourcing of fact-checking

“…Research specifically focused on factchecking has been narrower in scope, often but not entirely concerned with trends and developments in the United States (see Nieminen and Rapeli, 2019: 306). Work is emerging in other parts of the world with recent case studies in Europe (Brandtzaeg et al, 2018;Çömlekçi, 2021;Lopez-Garcia et al, 2021;Lyons et al, 2020); Africa (Cheruiyot and Ferrer-Conill, 2018); Britain (Birks, 2019b); South America (Rodriguez-Perez et al, 2021); and Australia (Brookes, 2018a(Brookes, , 2018bWaller and Brookes, 2022). For the most part, however, these individual case studies or projects are yet to coalesce into sustained programs of research 1 or are influenced by questions and approaches emerging from foundational US-based studies.…”

Supporting Journalistic Trust Determinations: A Heuristic Analysis of News Trust Tools Through a Transparency Lens

“…In particular, 71% of Americans deem news publishers' commitment to transparency "very important" when making trust determinations (Knight Foundation, 2018). Tools designed to provide transparency around different aspects of the journalistic process have emerged recently, with some focused on sharing supporting documents, fact-checking claims in articles, and identifying potential misinformation on social media (Yang et al,2022;Mor & Reich, 2018;Rodríguez-Pérez et al, 2021;Schifferes et al, 2014).…”