A challenge
for design of protein–small-molecule recognition
is that incorporation of cavities with size, shape, and composition
suitable for specific recognition can considerably destabilize protein
monomers. This challenge can be overcome through binding pockets formed
at homo-oligomeric interfaces between folded monomers. Interfaces
surrounding the central homo-oligomer symmetry axes necessarily have
the same symmetry and so may not be well suited to binding asymmetric
molecules. To enable general recognition of arbitrary asymmetric substrates
and small molecules, we developed an approach to designing asymmetric
interfaces at off-axis sites on homo-oligomers, analogous to those
found in native homo-oligomeric proteins such as glutamine synthetase.
We symmetrically dock curved helical repeat proteins such that they
form pockets at the asymmetric interface of the oligomer with sizes
ranging from several angstroms, appropriate for binding a single ion,
to up to more than 20 Å across. Of the 133 proteins tested, 84
had soluble expression in E. coli, 47 had correct
oligomeric states in solution, 35 had small-angle X-ray scattering
(SAXS) data largely consistent with design models, and 8 had negative-stain
electron microscopy (nsEM) 2D class averages showing the structures
coming together as designed. Both an X-ray crystal structure and a
cryogenic electron microscopy (cryoEM) structure are close to the
computational design models. The nature of these proteins as homo-oligomers
allows them to be readily built into higher-order structures such
as nanocages, and the asymmetric pockets of these structures open
rich possibilities for small-molecule binder design free from the
constraints associated with monomer destabilization.