Data composition and taxonomic resolution in macroinvertebrate stream typology

Abstract

In the EU water framework directive (WFD) a typological framework is defined for assessing the ecological quality of water bodies in the future. The aim of this study was to test the effect of data composition and taxonomic resolution on this typology. The EU research projects AQEM and STAR provided 1660 samples of 48 stream types sampled all over the major geographical gradients in Europe. These stream types fit the WFD typological demands and fit to the major European geographic regions (ecoregions). The samples included gradients from reference conditions to samples with bad ecological quality. Despite standardisation, there were large differences between the participating countries concerning the number of taxa, the number of specimens, and the taxonomic resolution. The macroinvertebrate data were analysed by using detrended correspondence analysis (DCA). The distribution patterns using all samples, only reference samples, and only degraded samples showed that the use of species-level (or 'best available taxonomic' level) performed better at a practical (fine) scale in comparison to family-level. The analyses further showed that even the use of a standardised protocol can not easily overcome (i) differences in site conditions that force the researcher to deviate from the protocol as well as (ii) the experiences of the researcher(s) and (iii) the available taxonomic knowledge.

Site-occupancy modelling: A new approach to assess sensitivity of indicator species

“…The sensitivity of oligochaetes to quality habitat is generally referred down to class, family or subfamily levels (Cortelezzi et al, 2011;Linhares Frizzera and da Gama Alves, 2012). Theses higher taxonomic levels show a relatively wide ecological valence as a result of the large number of species, which may yield skewed results when assessing water quality (Verdonschot, 2006;Cortelezzi et al, 2011). However, at the species level, the oligochaetes are sensitive enough to enable their implementation as indicators of water-quality indices (Lin and Yo, 2008).…”

NoMBSI: a new, Non-lethal Method for Benthos Sampling and Identification for use in biological monitoring of flowing waters: preliminary results

“…Where considerations are restricted to such a subsample, no use is found for the remaining individuals in subsequent phases of assessment (e.g. Kornijow & Lechowska 2002;Kownacki et al, 2002;Verdonschot, 2006). In this way, traditional methods of biological monitoring not only fail to protect fragments of valuable natural resources adequately, but also become questionable on ethical grounds.…”

A Littoral Fauna Index for assessing the impact of lakeshore alterations in Alpine lakes

“…Authors are often looking for a balance between the operational and economic requirements against the level of information required to identify environmental gradients or the potential impact of stressors (Bowman and Bailey, ; Verdonschot, ; Monk et al ., ). Thus, the minimum level of taxonomic resolution or ‘taxonomic sufficiency’ (Ellis, ) is often tested (e.g.…”