After irradiation of a pentazadiene solution (in THF) in a cuvette by laser pulses, damped oscillations of the absorbance were observed and mistakenly interpreted as being of photochemical origin. Additional experiments gave results that were incompatible with our photochemical interpretation and led to the identification of convection as the physical mechanism behind the observed oscillations. A simulation model based on the Navier-Stokes equations reproduces the damped oscillations. Analytical formulas are given to estimate convection velocities in cuvettes and might help to prevent misinterpretation of photolysis experiments. They show that arbitrarily small horizontal temperature gradients lead to convection in even very thin cuvettes. In any standard temperature-controlled cuvette, the fluid has to be assumed to be in motion rather than at rest.
IntroductionThe first homogeneous chemical oscillator was observed in 1921 by W. C. Bray, and 30 years later, B. P. Belousov discovered another type of a homogeneous chemical oscillator (published only in 1958 because scientific journals rejected its publication for 7 years). Supported by models of A. M. Zhabotinskii and I. Prigogine in the 1960s and of R. J. Field, E. Körös and R. M. Noyes in the early 1970s, the reality of chemical oscillations in homogeneous solutions is now generally accepted. 1 Due to biological implications, the interest for new and different chemical oscillators is still very high. On this background, observations of unusual absorbance oscillations occurring after irradiation of a pentazadiene solution by laser pulses triggered our interest and our attempts to interpret them on a photochemical basis. 2 However, as we will show in this paper, the observed damped oscillations were caused by convection and not by photochemical reactions. We would like to add that convection, especially when combined with polymerization reactions, interfacial tension, and diffusion, can create a large variety of interesting phenomena that are investigated by different groups. [3][4][5][6][7] A search of the literature related to chemical oscillations shows that we are not the first to be misguided by convection. Laplante and Pottier, 8 after many inconclusive experiments, introduced microdust particles into their cell and illuminated them with a laser to prove the existence of a convection cell. It was induced by the opening of the cell for inspection, resulting in evaporation of solvent that cooled the surface and caused a hydrodynamic instability. Further, Epstein et al. 9 found that the "photochemical oscillations" claimed by Bose et al. 10 and others were of the same physical origin. Convective movement of fluids should therefore be considered the rule rather than the exception: The common idea of the fluid at rest in a cuvette, moving only upon stirring, can be dangerously misleading.Framework of Investigations. With investigations of azo compounds, we contribute to a major area of research, as documented by numerous publications and, e.g., the monograph on D...