Cyclopentadienyl (Cp), a classic ancillary ligand platform, can be chemically noninnocent in electrocatalytic H−H bond formation reactions via protonation of coordinated η 5 -Cp ligands to form η 4 -CpH moieties. However, the kinetics of η 5 -Cp ring protonation, ligand-to-metal (or metal-to-ligand) proton transfer, and the influence of solvent during H 2 production electrocatalysis remain poorly understood. We report in-depth kinetic details for electrocatalytic H 2 production with Fe complexes containing amine-functionalized Cp N3 ligands that are protonated via exogenous acid to generate via η 4 -Cp N3 H intermediates (Cp N3 = 6-amino-1,4-dimethyl-5,7-diphenyl-2,3,4,6-tetrahydrocyclopenta[b]pyrazin-6-yl). Under reducing conditions, state-of-the-art DFT calculations reveal that a coordinated solvent plays a crucial role in mediating stereo-and regioselective proton transfer to generate (endo-Cp N3 H)Fe(CO) 2 (NCMe), with other protonation pathways being kinetically insurmountable. To demonstrate regioselective endo-Cp N3 H formation, the isoelectronic model complex (endo-Cp N3 H)Fe(CO) 3 is independently prepared, and kinetic studies with the on-cycle hydride intermediate Cp N3 FeH(CO) 2 under CO cleanly furnish the ring-activated complex (endo-Cp N3 H)Fe(CO) 3 via metal-to-ligand proton migration. The on-cycle complex Cp N3 FeH(CO) 2 reacts with acid to release H 2 and regenerate [Cp N3 Fe(CO) 2 (NCMe)] + , which was found to be the TOF-determining step via DFT. Collectively, these experimental and computational results underscore the emerging importance of Cp ring activation, inner-sphere solvation, and metal−ligand cooperativity to perform proton-coupled electron transfer catalysis for chemical fuel synthesis.