“…Baumgartner et al 1992, Klyashtorin 1997, Zhen-Shan & Xian 2007. While 60 yr is a convenient period to use for modeling purposes (Loehle & Scafetta 2011, Zwolinski & Demer 2012, examination of empirical data of various types and durations leads different authors to speak of a '50-year cycle' (Chavez et al 2003), a 'quasi 60-year cycle' (Mazzarella & Scafetta 2011), a '50−70 year cycle' (Minobe 1997, 1999, Mantua & Hare 2002, Klyashtorin et al 2009), a '50−79 year cycle' (Humlum et al 2011), or a '50−75 year cycle' (Ware 1995). Given decidedly noisy signals, long periodicities relative to human lives and datasets, possible lag times, and limited or no understanding of mechanisms, it remains to be shown to what extent such reports are describing either the same or multiple, unconnected phenomena.…”