Curriculum reform: Why? What? How? and how will we know it works?

Abstract

In a recent IJHPR article, Dankner et al. describe a reform in one longitudinal strand within Basic Medical Education i.e.“ public health and preventive medicine curriculum” using a Competency Based Medical Education approach. This reform raises several concerns: What should prompt a medical school to change a curriculum? How should such change be conducted? What kinds of paradigms may inform such a change? What constitutes a success in a curricular reform? And, how can curricular reform be evaluated within a reasonable time framework?This commentary addresses these concerns and concludes that curricular reform should follow as much as possible the current wisdom of educational innovation and change strategy, follow a clear vision, mission, and selected educational paradigm, and pay attention to stakeholders, context, culture and politics. The design should allow for the emergence of unintended consequences. Implementation needs careful planning and monitoring and the evaluation should be multi-faceted. Finally, since all Israeli medical schools are now using the Competency Based Medical Education approach and aligning their curricula and testing accordingly, a fascinating collaborative opportunity exists to professionalize this process and hopefully make a positive impact.

Curriculum reform in Zimbabwe: An analysis of early childhood development centers state of readiness to embrace the new curriculum

“…In Israel, factors which influenced changes and developments in Chemistry curriculum included political, cultural socio-economic, and scientific, industrial and technological innovations. Similarly, Reis (2018) suggests that curriculum reform should follow a clear vision and mission, a selected educational paradigm, and pay attention to stakeholders, context, culture and politics.…”

Medical Educators’ Beliefs about the Alignment of Learning Goals, Teaching, and Assessment in the Context of Curriculum Changes: A Qualitative Study  Conducted at  an Iranian Medical School

“…Reform, particularly in an intricate system like a medical school, is full of problems such as resistance, power, inertia, and ego challenges which necessitate a planned method, as well [34].…”

Evaluating Training Need for Epidemic Control in Three Metropolitans: Implications for COVID-19 Preparedness in Vietnam

“…A study in the United States reported that 98.5% of undergraduate students received quite poor health education communication (28). Findings from a study in England also pointed out the gap in public health and epidemiology training curriculum, and reformation to improve the training for medical students has been started (29). In the LMIC group, 86% of Pakistan medical students were not satisfied with the epidemiology approach at the university (30).…”