Current Challenges of Digital Health Interventions in Pakistan: Mixed Methods Analysis

Abstract

Background Digital health is well-positioned in low and middle-income countries (LMICs) to revolutionize health care due, in part, to increasing mobile phone access and internet connectivity. This paper evaluates the underlying factors that can potentially facilitate or hinder the progress of digital health in Pakistan. Objective The objective of this study is to identify the current digital health projects and studies being carried out in Pakistan, as well as the key stakeholders involved in these initiatives. We aim to follow a mixed-methods strategy and to evaluate these projects and studies through a strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats (SWOT) analysis to identify the internal and external factors that can potentially facilitate or hinder the progress of digital health in Pakistan. Methods This study aims to evaluate digital health projects carried out in the last 5 years in Pakistan with mixed methods. The qualitative and quantitative data obtained from field surveys were categorized according to the World Health Organization’s (WHO) recommended building blocks for health systems research, and the data were analyzed using a SWOT analysis strategy. Results Of the digital health projects carried out in the last 5 years in Pakistan, 51 are studied. Of these projects, 46% (23/51) used technology for conducting research, 30% (15/51) used technology for implementation, and 12% (6/51) used technology for app development. The health domains targeted were general health (23/51, 46%), immunization (13/51, 26%), and diagnostics (5/51, 10%). Smartphones and devices were used in 55% (28/51) of the interventions, and 59% (30/51) of projects included plans for scaling up. Artificial intelligence (AI) or machine learning (ML) was used in 31% (16/51) of projects, and 74% (38/51) of interventions were being evaluated. The barriers faced by developers during the implementation phase included the populations’ inability to use the technology or mobile phones in 21% (11/51) of projects, costs in 16% (8/51) of projects, and privacy concerns in 12% (6/51) of projects. Conclusions We conclude that while digital health has a promising future in Pakistan, it is still in its infancy at the time of this study. However, due to the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, there is an increase in demand for digital health and implementation of health outcomes following global social distancing protocols, especially in LMICs. Hence, there is a need for active involvement by public and private organizations to regulate, mobilize, and expand the digital health sector for the improvement of health care systems in countries.

Mobile consulting (mConsulting) as an option for accessing healthcare services for communities in remote rural areas and urban slums in low- and middle- income countries: A mixed methods study

“…It is not intervention-led and has not been formally evaluated or written up for publication. This has also been noted elsewhere 91,92 and may be one reason why we only found a limited number of articles pertaining to mConsulting in the published literature since 2018, despite a growing body of evidence on mobile health more generally in LMIC settings 93 .…”

Digital health literacy intervention to support maternal, child and family health in primary healthcare settings of Pakistan during the age of coronavirus: study protocol for a randomised controlled trial

“…48 Another limitation is that interventions so far in the country have targeted general health and non-communicable diseases, and there have been no efforts to improve literacy for hygiene, sanitation and coronavirus management in disadvantaged women. 49 There have also been few interventions involving communitybased intervention and female community healthcare workers in Pakistan. 50 Difficulties in conducting digital interventions in LMICs include: (1) high costs and shortage of national and international funding for such projects, (2) problems related to internet access in remote areas, (3) barriers in communicating with semiliterate populations, and (4) lack of cultural acceptability with regard to the use of technology, especially for women.…”

Improving Healthcare Access through Digital Health: The Use of Information and Communication Technologies

“…A number of country studies have listed challenges and opportunities of using digital health solutions from legal, ethical, infrastructural, human and material resources, training, education, attitude, organizational, cultural and behavioral points of view [57][58][59][60][61][62][63][64][65][66]. These challenges may include: 1.…”