Culture, Institutions and Campaign Effects: Explaining the Outcome of Malta's EU Accession Referendum

Abstract

This survey examines the background to and the campaign preceding Malta's EU accession referendum. The result of the referendum, which was held on 8 March 2003, and which was the first of the EU accession referendums of 2003, was a 53.65% vote in support of membership, on a turnout of close to 91%. Explaining both the relatively low support for EU accession and the high turnout on referendum day involves weighing up the relative impact of distinctive features of Malta's political culture and institutional framework against more immediate campaign effects. While the conclusion is that the high turnout in the Maltese EU accession referendum can be traced to Malta's political culture, the relatively low but positive vote in favour of membership can only be fully understood by focusing on a range of factors, including campaign-related factors, such as the credibility of the arguments presented by the 'yes' and 'no' camps and the balance of resources available. The most important factor explaining the result of the Maltese referendum are, however, the cues provided by the political parties prior to and over the course of the referendum campaign.

Europeanisation in new member and candidate states

“…The unconsolidated party systems of the eastern candidate countries may be more susceptible to influence, not least through European transnational party organisations that have been particularly active (Dakowska 2002;Lewis 2003;Pridham 1999;Pridham 2005: 164-166 Another central focus is the politics of the accession referenda (Baun et al 2006;Cini 2004;Fowler 2004;Hanley 2004;Henderson 2004;Krašovec and Lajh 2004;Mikkel and Pridham 2004;Szczerbiak 2004;Szczerbiak andTaggart 2004a,b, 2005).…”

The Politics of Differentiated Integration: What do Governments Want? Country Report - Malta

“…The Malta EU membership referendum of 2003 saw the highest turnout in an EU membership referendum (91%) and the lowest support for joining in any of the nine countries that held referendums on joining the EU (53%). These statistics indicate the high levels of electoral participation in Malta, but also a fair degree of scepticism about the suitability and strategic advantage for Malta, a small state, of joining the EU (Cini, 2004). Some of these concerns were addressed in the run-up to EU accession.…”

The Anatomy of a Misfit: The 2014 European Election in Malta

“…With its new leader and party structure, Labour increased its margin over the Nationalists in the 2009 European election and, most importantly, won the 2013 national elections by a landslide. (Cini 2000) could finally coexist peacefully (Cini 2004;Pace 2005). The obvious political consequence of the path to membership was that incentives for any of the main parties to campaign against the EU were, at least for some time, removed from the system.…”