Culturally Based Explanations of Minority Students' Academic Achievement

Abstract

Some cultural ecologists have proposed a classification of minority groups as "autonomous," "immigrant," or "castelike," and have defended the dichotomies between "macro" and "micro," "explanatory" and "applied" ethnography. Other scholars, arguing against this position on both theoretical and empirical grounds, suggest that culture is crucially important at the collective and individual levels for the academic achievement and overall psychological adjustment of immigrant, refugee, and other minority children. The construction of learning environments guaranteeing academic success for all children requires theoretical and practical approaches that (1) recognize the significance of culture in specific instructional settings, (2) prevent stereotyping of minorities, (3) help resolve cultural conflicts in school, (4) integrate the home and the school cultures, and (5) stimulate the development of communicative and other skills that children need in order to participate meaningfully in the instructional process. These approaches have permitted applied ethnographers to rapidly turn failure into success. CULTURAL EXPLANATlONS OF MI-GRAPHlC RESEARCH NORITY ACHIEVEMENT, TAXONOMlES OF MINORITIES, ETHNO-

Motivation and Achievement: Is There an East Asian Model?

“…As Hernandez & Iyengar (2001) proposed, people are motivated only when the contexts fostered a perception consistent with their culturally related values or beliefs. Therefore, it is important to take the effects of cultural values, norms, and practices into account when applying operation and effects of academic motivation to students from different cultures (Ng, 2003;Trueba, 1988). Otherwise, we may be misguided by studies solely based on Western theories or concepts and motivate students in East Asia in a culturally inappropriate manner and vice versa.…”

Cultural Attributes and Adaptations Linked to Achievement Motivation Among Latino Adolescents

“…These theories range from biological determinism, which assumes genetic inferiority of minority children (Jensen, 1969) to theories that recognize the impact of different cultural settings on the development of children's skills and abilities (Trueba, 1989). Although earlier theories offered an explanation for why many students experience school difficulties, these explanations could not account for the school success experienced by many Latino students.…”

Migrant worker children: Conceptions of homelessness and implications for education

“…It is by understanding this meeting of cultures (or confrontation) that we can come to understand how the children become alienated and schools fail. The studies of Trueba (1988Trueba ( , 1989Trueba ( , 1990) and others (Delgado-Gaitan & Trueba, 1991) seek to characterize the cultures of the immigrant Latina/o child and argue that schools need to recognize the qualities of these cultures, respect, and work within them in order to make the child's educational experience successful. But to understand or characterize these cultures, or lifeworlds, as the everyday world of human experience we must acknowledge that these are intersubjective worlds of social action (Schwandt, 1997).…”