Cultural Variability in the Attribute Framing Effect

Abstract

An intriguing phenomenon that arises from decision making is that the decision maker’s choice is often influenced by whether the option is presented in a positive or negative frame, even though the options are, de facto, identical to one another. Yet, the impact of such differential framing of equivalent information, referred to as the attribute framing effect, may not be the same for every culture; rather, some cultures may be more readily influenced by the differentially valenced frames than others (i.e., showing a greater difference in evaluation in a positive vs. negative frame). The present study investigates to what extent and why cultures may differ in their sensitivity to the attribute framing effect. Participants were recruited from South Korea and the United States, cultures characterized by their focus on prevention and promotion, respectively, to test for the cultural variability in the attribute framing effect. The results revealed that Korean participants were markedly more influenced by the valence of the frame than North American participants. Regulatory focus explained why Koreas showed a greater sensitivity toward the attribute framing effect than North Americans. Specifically, a greater prevention (vs. promotion) orientation of Korean participants led them to show a greater evaluation gap in the positive and negative frames. Implications for cultural significance on the attribute framing effect are discussed.

When do persuasive messages on vaccine safety steer COVID-19 vaccine acceptance and recommendations? Behavioural insights from a randomised controlled experiment in Malaysia

“…39 However, this effect has not been thoroughly studied in an Asian context. Finally, given that individual decision and behaviour are intrinsically linked to context and culture, [40][41][42] there are reasons to believe that vaccination nudges ought to be adapted to low and middle-income countries (LMIC) such as Malaysia. However, there exists a paucity of information for using such nudges in LMICs, with most published evidence originating from developed countries.…”

Similarity as a safe haven: Similarity leads to satisfaction in prevention focus

“…For instance, Chi et al (2013) found that similarity in relationship standards and couple communication patterns were linked to higher marital satisfaction. Moreover, East Asians, known for their higher prevention focus compared to Americans (Cheon et al, 2021), may derive greater contentment from substantial self-partner similarity. This body of work suggests that cultural contexts could moderate the role of similarity in relationship dynamics, and as such, warrants more nuanced cross-cultural explorations.…”

Cultural Perspectives, Feelings and Coping Behaviors during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Case Study of Romanian Students

“…The way in which people react to the positive as well as to the negative factors that may affect their daily activities is determined by the culture that has shaped their personalities since human behavior, be it verbal or nonverbal, and is eminently culturebound [13,[20][21][22][23][24][25][26][27][28][29][30][31][32][33][34]. Thus, culture, broadly defined as "the collective programming of the mind that distinguishes the members of one group or category of people from others" [34] (p. 3), influences distinctively the way in which humans communicate, as E.T.…”